2018 RE-DRAFT
If we knew then what we know now, ESPN asks it’s SBNation correspondents to re-draft.
1. Cleveland Browns
Original pick: Baker Mayfield, QB
New pick: Baker Mayfield, QB
There’s zero reason to change this pick. Mayfield energized the team and city in a fantastic rookie season. — Pat McManamon
2. New York Giants
Original pick: Saquon Barkley, RB
New pick: Sam Darnold, QB
This has nothing to do with Barkley. He was everything the Giants expected and more. But the 5-11 campaign only punctuated this organization’s need for a quarterback with Eli Manning in decline. — Jordan Raanan
3. New York Jets (from IND)
Original pick: Sam Darnold, QB
New pick: Josh Allen, QB
After trading up from No. 6, the Jets were committed to taking a quarterback, even if it meant passing on Barkley. They ranked Josh Rosen over Josh Allen, but we’re reversing the order after seeing the way Allen outplayed Rosen as a rookie. — Rich Cimini
4. Cleveland Browns (from HOU)
Original pick: Denzel Ward, CB
New pick: Saquon Barkley, RB
Two factors here: The Browns had Barkley ranked among their top one or two players, and Nick Chubb’s rookie season means he would never be available in the second round. Barkley is a special talent and too good to pass up here. He and Mayfield put the best two players in the draft on the same offense. — Pat McManamon
5. Denver Broncos
Original pick: Bradley Chubb, OLB
New pick: Bradley Chubb, OLB
The same scenario stayed in place for the Broncos. With Mayfield and Darnold — the quarterbacks they liked best — off the board, they would have looked to trade down, as they did on draft day. But Denver would have scuttled those plans when Chubb was still available. The Broncos’ enthusiasm was well-founded, as Chubb was one of the league’s best rookies, finishing with 12 sacks. — Jeff Legwold
6. Indianapolis Colts (from NYJ)
Original pick: Quenton Nelson, G
New pick: Quenton Nelson, G
The board allowed the Colts to again take Nelson, who didn’t miss a snap and made the All-Pro team as a rookie. He was a major factor in the unit’s giving up an NFL-low 18 sacks. — Mike Wells
7. Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Original pick: Josh Allen, QB (BUF traded up)
New pick: Derwin James, S
The Bucs need an upgrade at safety, and James is a playmaker and a ball hawk. James’ physical style would be the perfect complement to Justin Evans’ range. James had three interceptions and eight pass breakups, and he has a shot at being named Defensive Rookie of the Year. — Jenna Laine
8. Chicago Bears
Original pick: Roquan Smith, LB
New pick: Roquan Smith, LB
Smith is still the choice. The Georgia product finished with a team-high 122 tackles — the second most tackles ever by a Bears rookie, behind only Pro Football Hall of Famer Brian Urlacher. — Jeff Dickerson
9. San Francisco 49ers
Original pick: Mike McGlinchey, OT
New pick: Darius Leonard, LB
McGlinchey was good, and the Niners don’t regret taking him, but a re-draft offers the benefit of hindsight. Knowing what we know about Reuben Foster and the team’s need for star power on defense, Leonard was simply too good to pass up. — Nick Wagoner
10. Oakland Raiders
Original pick: Josh Rosen, QB (ARI traded up)
New pick: Denzel Ward, CB
Keep the Raiders’ real first-round draft pick while adding a Pro Bowler to pair up with an emerging stud? Sign me up. Putting Ward opposite a finally healthy Gareon Conley, a former Ohio State teammate who had three picks in 2018, would provide a sense of familiarity. — Paul Gutierrez
11. Miami Dolphins
Original pick: Minkah Fitzpatrick, S
New pick: Lamar Jackson, QB
Fitzpatrick was a strong pick for the Dolphins, and he will be a central player for the defense for years to come. But they desperately need a young franchise quarterback. Jackson immediately speeds up the timeline on the team’s rebuild, allowing a smooth transition from Ryan Tannehill. — Cameron Wolfe
12. Buffalo Bills (from CIN)
Original pick: Vita Vea, DT (TB traded up)
New pick: Josh Rosen, QB
Some Bills fans were upset during the draft when Buffalo traded up to No. 7 and took Allen instead of Rosen. Some might not be happy that Rosen is the choice here, but he is the only remaining quarterback who makes sense without the ability to trade up. — Mike Rodak
13. Washington Redskins
Original pick: Daron Payne, DT
New pick: Minkah Fitzpatrick, S
Payne was a good choice; he’s a solid player. But the Redskins liked Fitzpatrick before the draft, and they might have taken him ahead of Payne. His versatility in the secondary is a major plus; he also provides a future leader in the backfield. Also, knowing that the Redskins can get Tim Settle in later rounds — as they did in April — allows them to bypass a defensive lineman here. — John Keim
14. Green Bay Packers
Original pick: Marcus Davenport, DE (NO traded up)
New pick: Jaire Alexander, CB
The Packers took Alexander at No. 18 after they traded picks, but they’d take him again at No. 14 after the impact he made on their defense. It appears they finally got it right with one of their early-round cornerback picks. Alexander was a pass-breakup machine as a rookie. — Rob Demovsky
15. Arizona Cardinals
Original pick: Kolton Miller, OT (OAK pick in ARI trade up)
New pick: Mike McGlinchey, OT
If all the quarterbacks are off the board at No. 15, Arizona needs the next-best thing: someone to protect the quarterback. Drafting McGlinchey could give Arizona a young right tackle to complement D.J. Humphries at left tackle. — Josh Weinfuss
16. Baltimore Ravens
Original pick: Tremaine Edmunds, LB (BUF traded up)
New pick: Calvin Ridley, WR
With Lamar Jackson being selected in the top 10 instead of lasting until the bottom of the first round, the Ravens take the top wide receiver in the draft. Baltimore has repeatedly needed more playmakers on the outside, and Ridley can make an immediate impact, especially in the red zone. Under this scenario, however, the Ravens wouldn’t land their future franchise quarterback, and Joe Flacco likely remains the starter in 2019. — Jamison Hensley
17. Los Angeles Chargers
Original pick: Derwin James, S
New pick: Leighton Vander Esch, LB
With James off the board in the top 10, the Chargers fill another need at linebacker. They struggled to stop the run in a humbling loss to the Patriots in the divisional round with linebackers Denzel Perryman, Jatavis Brown and Kyzir White all on injured reserve. Vander Esch adds athleticism and playmaking ability. — Eric D. Williams
18. Seattle Seahawks
Original pick: Jaire Alexander, CB (GB traded up)
New pick: Tremaine Edmunds, LB
The Seahawks drafted Rashaad Penny to reinforce their run-centric offense after trading down at the end of Round 1. Penny showed some encouraging flashes, and he projects to have a larger role next season, but Edmunds is the better choice in this scenario. He would have been valuable when K.J. Wright went out because of a knee injury. — Brady Henderson
19. Dallas Cowboys
Original pick: Leighton Vander Esch, LB
New pick: Dallas Goedert, TE
The Cowboys liked Goedert entering the draft. Although this might be a little high for a tight end, there’s not a defensive player worth selecting at a position of need, as Vander Esch was last April. — Todd Archer
20. Detroit Lions
Original pick: Frank Ragnow, C/G
New pick: Will Hernandez, G
I could have stuck with Ragnow here because he played well as a rookie. But considering how the club used Ragnow — as a guard, not a center — Hernandez seemed to make more sense because he is a natural guard who had a strong season and could be a future stalwart. Detroit couldn’t have gone wrong with either player, though. — Michael Rothstein
21. Cincinnati Bengals (from BUF)
Original pick: Billy Price, C
New pick: Frank Ragnow, C
Ragnow had the edge over Price in the original draft, and with him available, the Bengals stick with the same position but get their first choice. Since Ragnow also can play guard, the Bengals could’ve played him ahead of Alex Redmond and allowed Trey Hopkins to play center, giving them some flexibility. — Katherine Terrell
22. Buffalo Bills (from KC)
Original pick: Rashaan Evans, LB (TEN traded up)
New pick: Billy Price, C
The Bills’ offensive line was a disaster, and it will be a focal point of the 2019 offseason. Ragnow would have been the choice here, but the Bills will settle for Price. — Mike Rodak
23. New England Patriots (from LAR)
Original pick: Isaiah Wynn, OT/G
New pick: Daron Payne, DT
The Patriots might have their left tackle of the future in Wynn, so the move to Payne is only a result of Wynn’s spending his rookie season on injured reserve after tearing his Achilles tendon. Payne played at Alabama under Nick Saban, one of Bill Belichick’s close friends in the business, and he plays a hard-to-fill position at the heart of the line of scrimmage. The pick also forecasts ahead to 2019, when Malcom Brown and Danny Shelton are unrestricted free agents. — Mike Reiss
24. Carolina Panthers
Original pick: DJ Moore, WR
New pick: DJ Moore, WR
Nothing would have changed here. The Panthers needed a top wide receiver and felt Moore was the best in the draft, selecting him over Ridley. With Ridley gone here, the option remained Moore, who proved worthy of being the No. 1 receiver the second half of the season. — David Newton
25. Tennessee Titans
Original pick: Hayden Hurst, TE (BAL pick from TEN trade up)
New pick: Harold Landry, OLB
Landry was the best remaining edge rusher on the board, and that was a position of need for the Titans. Instead of giving up draft capital to move up and pick Landry in the second round, the team picks him here. Landry gives the Titans a promising player who can anchor their pass rush for years to come, which is especially important with the expiring contracts for Derrick Morgan and Brian Orakpo. — Turron Davenport
26. Atlanta Falcons
Original pick: Calvin Ridley, WR
New pick: Braden Smith, G/OT
The Falcons should have considered upgrading the offensive line over adding another receiver to begin with, so why not look at a versatile lineman such as Smith? He is capable of playing guard and tackle, and he would have been a starter on the Falcons’ line. — Vaughn McClure
27. New Orleans Saints
Original pick: Rashaad Penny, RB (SEA traded up with GB from earlier NO deal)
New pick: Marcus Davenport, DE
This is an easy choice for the Saints, since they land the same guy at No. 27 after trading all the way up to No. 14 to get him in the real thing. The reason New Orleans coveted Davenport was that elite edge rushers have become the second-hardest commodity to acquire, after quarterbacks. He has the chance to become one after a promising rookie year that included 4.5 sacks and 12 QB hits. — Mike Triplett
28. Pittsburgh Steelers
Original pick: Terrell Edmunds, S
New pick: Nick Chubb, RB
With Le’Veon Bell most likely heading to a new team, the Steelers have a chance to rebuild their running game and provide more balance for the offense. Chubb is the best back in the draft not named Saquon Barkley and can pair with James Conner for a vicious tandem. The top defensive playmakers were off the board, so Pittsburgh must get secondary help in the second round. — Jeremy Fowler
29. Jacksonville Jaguars
Original pick: Taven Bryan, DT
New pick: Christian Kirk, WR
The Jaguars needed to add a playmaker — not take a player with an eye toward 2019 — and Kirk is the best receiver on the board here. — Mike DiRocco
30. Minnesota Vikings
Original pick: Mike Hughes, CB
New pick: James Daniels, C/G
Would drafting an interior lineman at No. 30 have solved all of the Vikings’ problems along the offensive line? Probably not. But going with Daniels, who became a full-time starter for the Bears around the same time Brian O’Neill became a full-time starter in Minnesota, would have allowed Mike Remmers to move back to right tackle and aided some of the Vikings’ issues at guard. — Courtney Cronin
31. New England Patriots
Original pick: Sony Michel, RB
New pick: Sony Michel, RB
As he showed in a divisional-round win over the Chargers, 5-foot-11, 215-pound Michel can be a go-to option in the most important game of the season. Asked what traits stand out in Michel, Bill Belichick said, “He’s had a lot of production in his career; we’d seen it certainly when he was in college. Good vision. Strong. Runs with good pad level. Gains yards after contact. He’s got a good set of running skills.” — Mike Reiss
32. Philadelphia Eagles
Original pick: Lamar Jackson, QB (BAL traded up)
New pick: Courtland Sutton, WR
The Eagles’ first selection in the real draft came at No. 49, as they picked tight end Dallas Goedert, who was snatched up by Dallas here. The Eagles need a steady presence opposite Alshon Jeffery, and Sutton would provide that. Philly will gladly take 6-3, 216-pound Sutton, who had 42 catches for 704 yards and four TDs for the Broncos. His 16.8 yards per reception ranked seventh in the NFL. — Tim McManus
|