2023 DRAFT
Matt Miller and Jordan Reid of ESPN.com have a dual draft – need vs. best athlete.
So we asked our NFL draft analysts to explore both sides of the table for all 31 first-round picks. First, Matt Miller named a prospect who would best fill every team’s biggest (or in some cases, second-biggest) need. Second, Jordan Reid pointed to the prospect who would give each team maximum value and satisfy a “best player available” approach. Repeat picks weren’t allowed, so each selection was based on the current board for each analyst. The lower we get in Round 1, the more variety you’ll see. Essentially, we tried to lay out a few options for every front office gearing up for a Day 1 pick.
Let’s get to it, starting with an easy one in Carolina.
1. Carolina Panthers (from CHI)
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Bryce Young, QB, Alabama
The Panthers need a lot of things, but no position is of bigger importance than quarterback. Since the departure of Cam Newton in 2020, quarterback has been the Panthers’ annual biggest need. And they didn’t just trade up to No. 1 to take a receiver. Young is my top overall quarterback and gives Carolina its new face of the franchise.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Bryce Young, QB, Alabama
While Young isn’t my No. 1 overall player, he is the top-ranked quarterback and is right near the top of my board, so this still checks the “best value” box for me. After trial runs with veterans like Baker Mayfield and Sam Darnold, the Panthers could get a franchise signal-caller to build around.
2. Houston Texans
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: C.J. Stroud, QB, Ohio State
The Texans need a post-Deshaun Watson quarterback in the worst way. With a good offensive line already in place, Stroud would step into an offense that is seeking a captain and point guard — and that’s why he fits so well in Houston.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Will Anderson Jr., OLB, Alabama
Yes, this will almost definitely be a quarterback. But if we’re looking strictly at value, Anderson is the No. 1 overall prospect in this class. No, taking Stroud isn’t a reach by any means, but Anderson is a defensive star in the making at a premium position.
3. Arizona Cardinals
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Will Anderson Jr., OLB, Alabama
The Cardinals might have the worst roster in the NFL, but the biggest hole comes at pass-rusher. The former regime threw a ton of draft capital at versatile defenders, but there isn’t a player on the roster who will scare opposing offenses by consistently getting after the QB. Anderson was the best defender in college football the past two years and has instant-impact ability and a double-digit sack future.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Jalen Carter, DT, Georgia
Carter has a strong case himself as the best player in the draft, and despite a slight slip in his stock during the pre-draft process, he would make Arizona’s front much better and give it a disruptive presence in the middle of the defense.
4. Indianapolis Colts
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Will Levis, QB, Kentucky
Going back to Andrew Luck’s retirement, the Colts have attempted to fill the QB void through a series of bad decisions. The best-case scenario for the Colts would be one of the top two quarterbacks falling here, but with Young and Stroud gone on my side of things, it has to be Levis. His ability to play right away pushes him over Florida’s Anthony Richardson for me.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: C.J. Stroud, QB, Ohio State
I think we’d all be shocked if Stroud is still here at No. 4, but based on how the value-only board is playing out, he’d more than qualify as the pick here. He’s an extremely accurate passer who would not only take care of a problem area for Indy but also be considered a straight-up steal inside the top five.
5. Seattle Seahawks (from DEN)
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Tyree Wilson, DE, Texas Tech
The Seahawks have to find more juice in the pass-rush department, and Wilson brings plenty of that with his first-step quickness and length off the edge. Wide receiver or quarterback of the future are worth a look here, but the No. 1 need is to find a true starter on the edge, even after the addition of Dre’Mont Jones in free agency.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Tyree Wilson, DE, Texas Tech
The stars align here, as Seattle also takes the best available prospect in the trenches. Wilson is the type of player the Seahawks tend to gravitate toward. His length, strength and physicality fit well with their defense, and even though he still has some developing to do, Wilson would be a big upgrade on a young defensive line.
6. Detroit Lions (from LAR)
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Jalen Carter, DT, Georgia
Detroit has good edge rushers and spent to add three new starters to the secondary in free agency, but the middle of the defensive line is wide open. Carter’s off-field question marks must be vetted by any team that drafts him — in March he pleaded no contest to charges of reckless driving and racing in connection with a crash that killed a Bulldogs teammate and a recruiting staff member — but the Lions have a good structure in place to help him transition to the pros.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Christian Gonzalez, CB, Oregon
After trading Jeff Okudah to the Falcons, the Lions now have a gaping hole at outside corner in their secondary. And after a quick look at the board, the Lions are in luck. Gonzalez is the top-ranked corner on my board and the No. 6 player overall. He’d be a great add for an ascending team.
7. Las Vegas Raiders
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Devon Witherspoon, CB, Illinois
This is not a good roster, but perhaps the biggest problem is at cornerback. With Nate Hobbs and Brandon Facyson penciled in as starters right now, it’s obvious the Raiders must come out of the draft with at least one new starter candidate there. Witherspoon is my top cornerback in this class. He’s a 6-foot, 181-pound wrecking ball and sticky cover man who would immediately be the team’s top option outside.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Peter Skoronski, OT, Northwestern
The Raiders could go a lot of different directions with this pick, but if you want value, Skoronski at No. 7 overall is pretty good. He’s capable of playing all five positions up front and could quickly become a key part of the protection for quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo.
8. Atlanta Falcons
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Lukas Van Ness, DE, Iowa
Depending on how you feel about QB Desmond Ridder, you might go quarterback here. The Falcons, however, continue to say that Ridder is the starter for 2023, so we’ll take their word for it and look at defensive end. The interior of the defensive line is stacked, but Atlanta could use some speed and power coming off the edge. Van Ness has jaw-dropping power, length and burst.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Bijan Robinson, RB, Texas
Robinson is a top-five player on my board. Positional downgrade aside, he would likely be among the best prospects on most teams’ boards by this point in the draft, too. Pairing Tyler Allgeier with Robinson gives a run-heavy team a dynamic one-two punch in the backfield. While such a pick could raise some eyebrows on draft night, adding one of the best players in the draft at this spot was a no-brainer in this exercise.
9. Chicago Bears (from CAR)
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Peter Skoronski, OT, Northwestern
With Braxton Jones and Teven Jenkins penciled in as starters, there are legitimate questions at offensive tackle. Both players have potential and talent, but if we’re talking what this roster needs right now, it’s a franchise-caliber left tackle. Skoronski is a mauler and a technician, and he would immediately boost the entire offensive line and give Justin Fields a bodyguard on his backside.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Devon Witherspoon, CB, Illinois
Witherspoon is the top remaining player on my board. Yes, there are bigger needs, but adding an aggressive corner to coach Matt Eberflus’ defense would help the continued retool on that side of the ball. Witherspoon’s instincts and polished technique fit in well here.
10. Philadelphia Eagles (from NO)
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Calijah Kancey, DT, Pittsburgh
After re-signing key veterans in free agency to keep most of the defense intact, the Eagles can start thinking about the future. Finding the next Fletcher Cox would be nice, but how about an impact three-down pass-rusher? Kancey is more likely to go later in Round 1 and is outside the top 20 on my board, but this is the No. 1 need in Philadelphia.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Jaxon Smith-Njigba, WR, Ohio State
Imagine adding Smith-Njigba to an offense that already includes Jalen Hurts, A.J. Brown, DeVonta Smith and Dallas Goedert? One of the top offenses in the league would be getting my top-ranked wideout in this class. We saw the Cowboys go “best player available” with receiver CeeDee Lamb in 2020, and that worked out well.
11. Tennessee Titans
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Anthony Richardson, QB, Florida
The Ryan Tannehill era is likely on its last legs, and Malik Willis hasn’t shown the tools to be the answer at quarterback. Richardson’s physical traits and upside are outstanding. He has a huge arm, awesome running ability and a 6-foot-4 build that can punish NFL defenses. He needs time to develop, but his ceiling is unlimited.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Anthony Richardson, QB, Florida
Richardson will likely go a lot higher than this, but he’s No. 14 overall on my board. Taking the position into consideration, I think this would safely be considered strong value at No. 11 as the heir apparent to Tannehill. This offense is predicated on quick-game timing-based passing and downhill running, which seems like a perfect scheme to groom Richardson into an eventual starter down the road.
12. Houston Texans (from CLE)
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Jaxon Smith-Njigba, WR, Ohio State
With quarterback set after the No. 1 overall pick, now it’s time to look at the second-biggest need … wide receiver. Even after adding Roberts Woods and Noah Brown, and accounting for a healthy John Metchie III, the Texans lack a true WR1. JSN is the best receiver in the draft class and projects as that true No. 1 target.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Joey Porter Jr., CB, Penn State
The 12th-ranked player on my board goes to the team owning the No. 12 overall pick. Pairing Porter with Stingley would give the Texans two building blocks on the perimeter. And Porter is tailor-made for the versatile defensive scheme of DeMeco Ryans.
13. New York Jets
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Paris Johnson Jr., OT, Ohio State
We’re assuming Aaron Rodgers becomes a Jet, so quarterback isn’t our target position. Instead, I’m looking at left tackle, which has been an issue and must be addressed with a long-term solution. Johnson is a long, easy-moving tackle who is a day one starter on the left side.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Paris Johnson Jr., OT, Ohio State
The Jets were decimated with injuries at offensive tackle last season, so I’m sure they’d love to land the No. 11-ranked player in Johnson. He is full of potential and is still in the early stages of playing the position.
14. New England Patriots
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Broderick Jones, OT, Georgia
Trent Brown is the starting left tackle in New England right now, but at 30 years old, he’s not a long-term play. So left tackle has to be the first area of improvement in the draft. Jones needs seasoning, but his traits — power, length and quickness — are those of an NFL starter.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Broderick Jones, OT, Georgia
Ranked 13th on my board, Jones has a very high ceiling. He started only 19 games during his career at Georgia, and Jones is just scratching the surface of what he could become in the future. His long arms, foot quickness and hand strength will give him an opportunity to quickly become one of the best young blockers in the league.
15. Green Bay Packers
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Zay Flowers, WR, Boston College
It’s not just a running joke that the Packers don’t pick receivers early in the draft, it’s a reality that has left the roster thin at the position. Christian Watson and Romeo Doubs have promise, but more help is required. Flowers is the dynamic deep threat and yards-after-catch menace that this offense lacks.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Myles Murphy, DE, Clemson
With Rashan Gary recovering from a torn right ACL, the Packers are in search of consistent options opposite of Preston Smith. Guess who would be the top player available if the board fell this way? Murphy is an explosive pass-rushing prospect who checks a lot of the boxes for the Packers’ defense.
16. Washington Commanders
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Christian Gonzalez, CB, Oregon
The Commanders’ entire secondary could use an upgrade, but especially at cornerback, where Kendall Fuller and Benjamin St-Juste are the current starters. Gonzalez has elite positional traits, including length, speed and a 6-foot-1 frame. Plus, he turned in four interceptions during his first season with Oregon in 2022.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Darnell Wright, OT, Tennessee
I’m sticking to the board while also continuing to revamp Washington’s offensive front with Wright, who gives the Commanders an option at right or left tackle. He could provide immediate competition for Charles Leno Jr. but also a security blanket if the Andrew Wylie signing doesn’t work out as planned. But Wright could also be an early starter on the interior.
17. Pittsburgh Steelers
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Darnell Wright, OT, Tennessee
The Steelers have built an offensive line without investing early-round picks, but that product shows on the field. After adding free agent right guard Isaac Seumalo, plugging in a dominant run-blocker like Wright next to him gives Pittsburgh a legitimate strength and would boost the run game for star back Najee Harris.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Jordan Addison, WR, USC
With my 17th-ranked (Nolan Smith) and 18th-ranked (Addison) players still on the board, I’m going with the latter. Addison would provide another threat on the perimeter for the Steelers. And remember, quarterback Kenny Pickett and Addison already have chemistry from their days at Pitt, where they won a conference championship and got Addison a Biletnikoff Award.
18. Detroit Lions
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Drew Sanders, ILB, Arkansas
Detroit got a defensive tackle at No. 6, but we can all agree it still has work to do on defense. Linebacker is a weak link, and Sanders would be the true three-down presence the team currently lacks. He had 9.5 sacks last year, too, which shows his versatility as a defender. Sanders is my No. 39 overall player, but he fills the Lions’ largest remaining hole here.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Nolan Smith, OLB, Georgia
As was the case at No. 6 when we picked Gonzalez for Detroit, value meshes with need here. An explosive and powerful rusher off the edge, Smith would provide the Lions with another versatile rusher alongside Aidan Hutchinson and James Houston.
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Anton Harrison, OT, Oklahoma
OK, now I’m starting to reach. Harrison is my No. 62 overall player in the class, but there’s no denying the need for an offensive tackle in Tampa Bay after it released Donovan Smith. Harrison is a talented tackle with good movement skills but must improve his play strength. The value isn’t here with this pick, and it highlights the significant drop-off at the position after the top four are off the board.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Zay Flowers, WR, Boston College
There are some people around the league who believe that Flowers is the most dynamic player in this year’s draft class. Teaming him up with Mike Evans, Chris Godwin and Russell Gage could take the Bucs’ offense to another level. With question marks at quarterback, adding another pass-catcher helps, but I’d imagine Tampa Bay goes another direction here, most likely leaning toward the “need” side.
20. Seattle Seahawks
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Jordan Addison, WR, USC
Wilson at No. 5 checked off the pass rush, so the Seahawks are free to focus on offense and adding a WR3 who can become a front-line starter once Tyler Lockett has moved on. Addison is an efficient route runner with sure hands and the ability to play immediately from the slot. He has great quickness and instincts.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Calijah Kancey, DT, Pitt
Kancey isn’t quite the best player still on my board, but he’s up there (No. 22). And the Seahawks would be adding an explosive option on the inside. Kancey has the potential to revolutionize Seattle’s passing defense the moment he steps on the field as a rookie. His hand aggression and first-step burst are the best of any interior defender in the 2023 class.
21. Los Angeles Chargers
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Jalin Hyatt, WR, Tennessee
A deep threat with top-tier speed is exactly what the Chargers’ offense has been missing. Even if you like Josh Palmer as WR3 — and I do — there’s no denying the offense must evolve past the possession-style receivers like Keenan Allen and Mike Williams. Hyatt opens up the offense for more deep shots from day one.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Michael Mayer, TE, Notre Dame
I’d love to get Los Angeles a receiver, but the value isn’t there. My next-best WR is ranked outside the top 30. But the Chargers lack true options behind Allen and Williams, and there are two tight ends ranked higher — including Mayer, who is 21st on my board. The addition would not only give quarterback Justin Herbert another target but also provide Los Angeles with a key blocker in the run game.
22. Baltimore Ravens
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Joey Porter Jr., CB, Penn State
The Ravens signed free agent Odell Beckham Jr. so there isn’t a massive need at wide receiver any longer — though they should still add at least one more pass-catcher. But the spot opposite Marlon Humphrey at cornerback is open following Marcus Peters’ departure. Porter is long, physical and aggressive, and I’ve actually comped him to Humphrey. I love his scheme fit here.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Deonte Banks, CB, Maryland
Porter isn’t here, but Banks is, and he still offers really good value as a top-20 prospect. And like Porter, he is a big and aggressive corner who displays high-level instincts at the position.
23. Minnesota Vikings
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Deonte Banks, CB, Maryland
I was close to going quarterback here — yes, it’s a need — but after digging into the Vikings’ roster one more time, it’s obvious that cornerback is main spot where major improvement must happen in a hurry. The Vikings lack size and playmaking ability in the defensive starting lineup, and Banks brings both to the table.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Will Levis, QB, Kentucky
Levis is still projected to go in the top 10, so don’t get your hopes up, Vikings fans. But Levis is the 25th-ranked player on my board, and if we were taking positional bias out of it, this is the range that better fits his NFL projection. Minnesota will be looking for a heir apparent to Kirk Cousins — who is entering the final year of his deal — during the draft. Levis’ skill set aligns well with coach Kevin O’Connell’s system, and he would give the Vikings a young answer under center moving forward.
24. Jacksonville Jaguars
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Mazi Smith, DT, Michigan
The middle of the defensive line in Jacksonville could use an upgrade, and Smith can be the anchor there between Josh Allen and Travon Walker. The Jaguars currently have solid players on that D-line, but Smith has the size, power and quickness to become a true force.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Brian Branch, CB/S, Alabama
Tyson Campbell and Darious Williams are manning the outside corner spots, but the Jaguars are in need of a nickel corner/safety hybrid. Branch fits that perfectly as a physical presence with versatility. But I’m picking him here based on value; Branch is the top name on my best remaining list.
25. New York Giants
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Emmanuel Forbes, CB, Mississippi State
Many will argue for wide receiver here, but the Giants have added enough players that the depth chart looks solid, even if it still lacks one true star. The same cannot be said at cornerback, where an outside starter is a big-time need. Forbes lacks great size at 166 pounds, but he had 14 interceptions and six pick-sixes over his college career.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Lukas Van Ness, DE, Iowa
Perhaps the Giants reach if no receiver or corner is right at the top of the deck at No. 25, but that’s not my aim here today. For what it’s worth, they do lack depth on the defensive front, and Van Ness would create a dynamic duo with Kayvon Thibodeaux and provide competition for Jihad Ward.
26. Dallas Cowboys
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Michael Mayer, TE, Notre Dame
The Cowboys tended to major problem areas at receiver and offensive line in free agency, but now tight end is a weakness on the roster with Dalton Schultz gone to Houston. Mayer is a three-down tight end with above-average blocking ability and the surest hands of any prospect at the position.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Dalton Kincaid, TE, Utah
I have the same position here, Matt. But Mayer is off my board, and Kincaid is one of the top two guys still available. He fits well with Dallas, which needs a dynamic “F” tight end. He would provide value in the passing game and could quickly fill the void left by Schultz.
27. Buffalo Bills
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Nolan Smith, OLB, Georgia
We saw how important the pass rush is to Buffalo last year when Von Miller went down with an ACL injury. Now the Bills have to invest in finding the eventual Miller replacement. Smith is a blur coming off the edge and has the length and quickness to be a problem for offensive tackles in space.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: O’Cyrus Torrence, G, Florida
My top-ranked interior blocker, Torrence is tremendous value here for the Bills. Even after signing Connor McGovern, they don’t have much depth along the interior offensive front. Torrence could be an immediate answer at either guard spot as a strong, dependable blocker.
28. Cincinnati Bengals
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: DJ Turner, CB, Michigan
Depending on what happens with offensive tackle Jonah Williams, who requested a trade after the team signed Orlando Brown Jr. to play left tackle, the Bengals’ biggest need could end up being right tackle. But for now, it’s cornerback, where Eli Apple & Co. were picked on in the playoffs last season. Mike Hilton is a star in the slot, but an outside cornerback is a Day 1 priority. Turner has great speed and could help.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Dawand Jones, OT, Ohio State
Yes, I’m higher on Jones than most. But I’m basing this off my board, and I have him ranked at No. 28 overall. Plus, the Bengals could form the biggest set of offensive tackles in the league by complementing Brown with the 6-foot-8, 374-pound Jones. And the pick would give quarterback Joe Burrow a nice boost in protection should Williams get traded.
29. New Orleans Saints (from SF/MIA/DEN)
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Myles Murphy, DE, Clemson
The Saints have never really replaced Trey Hendrickson, and they lost starter Marcus Davenport at defensive end this offseason. The time is now for the front office to invest in a pass-rusher who can make it to his second contract in New Orleans. Murphy doesn’t have great bend, but his speed and length are top-tier traits.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Bryan Bresee, DT, Clemson
Murphy is long gone for me, but I do think another Clemson player could present good value. After losing David Onyemata and Shy Tuttle, Bresee could walk into the facility and be an immediate contributor at defensive tackle. He’s stout at the point of attack, nimble as a pass-rusher and can penetrate the first level — all of which gives him a chance to have an impact as a rookie.
30. Philadelphia Eagles
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Bijan Robinson, RB, Texas
The Eagles have so few needs and checked off the biggest one at No. 10 with a defensive tackle. So why not running back? Rashaad Penny hasn’t been able to stay healthy, and Kenneth Gainwell is a role player. Robinson would solve the running back question for the next five years at a very inexpensive clip.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Jahmyr Gibbs, RB, Alabama
It’s a nice coincidence that the top player still on my board also happens to be a running back, though it’s my RB2. Gibbs could be a big contributor in the passing game and use his big-play ability in the run game to be a real asset for a loaded Eagles offense.
31. Kansas City Chiefs
Miller’s pick that fills a big need: Bryan Bresee, DT, Clemson
The Chiefs are coming off a Super Bowl victory in which the offense didn’t have a wide receiver record a 1,000-yard season, so this team can win in a variety of ways. GM Brett Veach has drafted very well to stock the roster with young, cheap talent. However, there isn’t a defensive tackle under contract past the 2023 season, which makes the interior a huge question mark for the future. Let’s go with Bresee to close things out.
Reid’s pick that gets best value: Quentin Johnston, WR, TCU
Through 30 picks, my top 30 prospects have all come off the board. The next three are linebacker Drew Sanders (Arkansas), edge rusher Will McDonald IV (Iowa State) and Johnston, and they are all pretty close in grade. I think K.C. would be pumped to land Johnston here as a high-end playmaker for quarterback Patrick Mahomes. He’s a different type of wideout than what’s currently on the Chiefs’ roster, as a big-body target who can be used in various ways in Andy Reid’s diverse playbook. |