UNDER 25 RANKINGS
Aaron Schatz of FootballOutsiders, writing at ESPN.com calculates which teams have the best talent under age 25. It is hugely long, so we are going to severely edit it with a concentration on the teams at the top (Miami, Washington, etc) and the bottom (Houston).
Just how important is the quarterback position when it comes to evaluating the young talent on an NFL team?
That’s the question that faced us as we put together this year’s ranking of all 32 NFL teams based on talent under 25 years old. Is it better to be the Los Angeles Chargers, where Justin Herbert might be the most valuable young asset in the entire league after establishing himself with one of the best rookie quarterback seasons in NFL history? Or is it better to be the Washington Football Team, where the defense is packed with young talent led by Defensive Rookie of the Year Chase Young — but the quarterback, Ryan Fitzpatrick, is emphatically not included in any calculation of talent under the age of 25?
In the end, we ended up with a third team in the No. 1 spot: the Miami Dolphins. The Dolphins have amassed a lot of draft capital in recent years, and they’ve used those picks well. Like the Chargers, they have a promising young quarterback, even if his rookie year didn’t demonstrate the same amount of promise. Like the Washington Football Team, they have young talent all across the roster, although there’s no star who looks quite as stellar as Young. Unlike Los Angeles or Washington, the young talent in Miami includes both a quarterback and is deep at other positions.
These ratings consider not just talent under 25 but also the value and length of those players’ current contracts. This will push up the teams with productive players who have several years left on inexpensive rookie contracts and push down the teams that have already had to, or will soon have to, pay their experienced young talent. Check out the bottom of the article for more on our methodology.
Here are our rankings for this season. All ages are as of Sept. 1. Blue-chip players are cornerstone assets from whom teams will likely derive their biggest future value.
1. Miami Dolphins
2020 ranking: 16
Blue-chip players: QB Tua Tagovailoa, OT Austin Jackson, WR Jaylen Waddle, DT Raekwon Davis
Notable graduated players: DL Christian Wilkins, OT Robert Hunt
It’s not hard to rank a team at No. 1 in young talent when they’ve had five first-round picks over the course of the last two seasons.
Those five first-rounders are led, of course, by last year’s fifth overall pick, quarterback Tua Tagovailoa. Many fans see Tagovailoa’s rookie season as a disappointment, but honestly it is only a disappointment if you compare him to the stellar season that Justin Herbert had for the Los Angeles Chargers. Most quarterbacks, even first-rounders, start their careers off slowly, and Tagovailoa was no exception. Tagovailoa ranked 26th among qualifying quarterbacks in both ESPN QBR and Football Outsiders DVOA. That was the worst of last year’s three first-round passers, but not worryingly so. Looking at history, Tagovailoa had a slightly above-average rookie season. His passing DVOA ranked him 20th out of 54 qualifying first-round rookie passers since 1983 (min. 200 passes).
However, Miami is on top because the young talent here goes far past just Tagovailoa. Let’s start on the offensive line, where the Dolphins started two rookies last year. They certainly played like rookies: Left tackle Austin Jackson was in the top 15 for blown blocks despite missing three games, while guard Solomon Kindley ranked 84th out of 111 interior linemen in snaps per blown block. But both linemen also showed promise for growth in their second seasons. On the defensive side of the ball, nose tackle Raekwon Davis played well enough that he made veteran Davon Godchaux expendable this offseason. And cornerback Noah Igbinoghene could be moving into the starting lineup if the Dolphins meet Xavien Howard’s trade request.
These rookies from 2020 are joined by the Dolphins’ incoming rookie class, which featured four picks in the top 50.
2. Washington Football Team
2020 ranking: 12
Blue-chip players: ER Chase Young, ER Montez Sweat, SS Kamren Curl, DT Daron Payne, LB Jamin Davis
Notable graduated players: WR Terry McLaurin, LB Cole Holcomb
Washington’s young talent is almost all about the defense, which makes sense since Washington finished third in defensive DVOA last season after one of the 10 biggest year-to-year improvements on that side of the ball in our entire database (since 1983).
3. Los Angeles Chargers
2020 ranking: 23
Blue-chip players: QB Justin Herbert, LB Kenneth Murray, OT Rashawn Slater
Notable graduated players: FS Derwin James
There’s a reasonable argument that the Chargers should be No. 1 simply because of Justin Herbert, whom our methodology ranked as the most valuable young asset in the league after his phenomenal rookie campaign in 2000.
There’s more talent here than just Herbert, but it’s not as deep as what we find in Miami or Washington. Kenneth Murray, 22, is a natural run-and-chase player, a quality tackler and run defender. He was not the coverage star his speed suggests he should be, ranking just 68th among qualifying linebackers in success rate in pass coverage last year, and his value to the Chargers is held down by the relative lesser importance of off-ball linebackers in the current NFL.
4. Baltimore Ravens
2020 ranking: 2
Blue-chip players: QB Lamar Jackson, LB Patrick Queen, WR Marquise Brown
Notable graduated players: LT Orlando Brown (also traded), CB Marlon Humphrey, TE Mark Andrews
Let’s start with Lamar Jackson, because not every team has someone who has won the NFL MVP who is still under 25 years of age. Jackson won’t turn 25 until Jan. 7. Yes, his play last season didn’t match his MVP play from the year before, but he still finished the year seventh in ESPN QBR and he’s still one of the league’s most valuable young assets.
Jackson’s top two wide receivers this year are likely to be under-25 players as well: Marquise “Hollywood” Brown is five months younger than Jackson, while first-round rookie Rashod Bateman doesn’t turn 22 until late November. Top running back J.K. Dobbins is also only 22 this season; he turns 23 in December.
On the defensive side of the ball, Baltimore’s young talent starts at the inside linebacker position with both Patrick Queen and Malik Harrison.
5. Jacksonville Jaguars
2020 ranking: 7
Blue-chip players: QB Trevor Lawrence, CB CJ Henderson, WR DJ Chark, WR Laviska Shenault
Notable graduated players: LB Myles Jack, OT Cam Robinson
The young talent here is led by first overall pick Lawrence, considered to be the best quarterback prospect to come out of college in nearly a decade. But there’s a lot more beyond Lawrence. The problem is that most of those players either aren’t under contract for much longer or haven’t fully fulfilled their potential.
In the first category, we find wide receiver DJ Chark, a 2018 second-round pick who has one more year before he becomes a free agent.
The second category is highlighted by edge rushers Josh Allen and K’Lavon Chaisson, first-round picks from the 2019 and 2020 drafts, respectively.
6. San Francisco 49ers
2020 ranking: 5
Blue-chip players: QB Trey Lance, ER Nick Bosa, LB Fred Warner, DT Javon Kinlaw, WR Brandon Aiyuk
Notable graduated players: WR Deebo Samuel
Here’s another team with a promising young quarterback, third overall pick Trey Lance. Lance doesn’t turn 22 until May. Whether he takes the starting job sometime during the 2021 season or not until 2022, he’ll be throwing to weapons that include 23-year-old Brandon Aiyuk, who gained 70 or more yards in six of his final seven games last season. Lance will be handing off to third-round rookie Trey Sermon (age 22), and second-round rookie Aaron Banks (age 23) will be blocking for him.
But the 49ers have even more outstanding young talent on defense than they do on offense. All-Pro middle linebacker Fred Warner, who is still just 24, excels in pass coverage and signed a five-year, $95 million extension that included $40.5 million guaranteed.
7. New York Giants
2020 ranking: 1
Blue-chip players: QB Daniel Jones, OT Andrew Thomas, DL Dexter Lawrence, RB Saquon Barkley, WR Kadarius Toney
Notable graduated players: SS Jabrill Peppers, G Will Hernandez
Here’s another team where a lot of the young talent still has a ton of potential it hasn’t grown into yet.
That starts with quarterback Daniel Jones.
Another player who has yet to meet his potential is offensive tackle Andrew Thomas, selected fourth overall in the 2020 draft.
On the defensive side of the ball, the biggest young talent is defensive end Dexter Lawrence, who hasn’t quite matched his projection as a run defender but may be a better pass-rusher than originally expected.
8. Tampa Bay Buccaneers
2020 ranking: 20
Blue-chip players: OT Tristan Wirfs, LB Devin White, FS Antoine Winfield
Notable graduated players: WR Chris Godwin
The Buccaneers have a ton of young talent after a couple of very successful drafts. Their most valuable asset under 25 is probably right tackle Tristan Wirfs, who ranked 11th among all tackles in snaps per blown block. That was well ahead of the other young tackles drafted before him last April. Wirfs turns 23 in January.
Starting safety Antoine Winfield is a physical playmaker, also from last year’s draft class. He turns 23 this month. Inside linebacker Devin White turned 23 in February, and he still has three years in Tampa Bay before his rookie contract runs out. White led all inside linebackers in sacks, hits, and hurries and tied for the league lead in defeats. The Bucs also restocked their pass rush with this year’s first-round pick, 22-year-old Joe Tryon.
The main reason Tampa Bay doesn’t rank even higher in these rankings is that a lot of their best players under 25 have contracts that run out soon.
9. Cincinnati Bengals
2020 ranking: 19
Blue-chip players: QB Joe Burrow, WR Tee Higgins, WR Ja’Marr Chase, FS Jessie Bates
Notable graduated players: LB Germaine Pratt, RB Joe Mixon
This ranking for the Bengals is almost entirely due to offense. We’ll start with 2020 first overall pick Joe Burrow, who ranked 24th in QBR in his shortened rookie season. If he’s healthy after last year’s ACL tear, the Bengals will be expecting a big jump in his second season. However, Burrow was somewhat old for a rookie last year and will turn 25 during the upcoming season (in December).
10. Carolina Panthers
2020 ranking: 17
Blue-chip players: LB/S Jeremy Chinn, DT Derrick Brown, QB Sam Darnold, ER Brian Burns, WR D.J. Moore, CB Jaycee Horn
Notable graduated players: RB Christian McCaffrey, CB Donte Jackson
There’s no one stellar value here to match Chase Young or some of the young quarterbacks we’ve mentioned already (Herbert, Lawrence, Burrow, etc.). However, the Panthers have a lot of young talent that’s pretty good or has pretty good potential.
11. New York Jets
2020 ranking: 8
Blue-chip players: QB Zach Wilson, OT Mekhi Becton, DL Quinnen Williams, G Alijah Vera-Tucker
Notable graduated players: CB Blessuan Austin, TE Christopher Herndon
The Jets’ young talent starts with the most recent draft, where New York had three picks in the top 34.
12. Arizona Cardinals
2020 ranking: 3
Blue-chip players: QB Kyler Murray, LB Isaiah Simmons, LB Zaven Collins
Notable graduated players: SS Budda Baker, C Mason Cole
This rating is very heavily based on 24-year-old Kyler Murray, who improved his QBR from 58.0 to 68.3 in his second NFL season.
Other than Murray, the main young talent on the Cardinals’ roster is right in the center of the defense. Versatile linebackers Isaiah Simmons and Zaven Collins can be used as run-stoppers, pass-rushers or in pass coverage. Simmons is still just 23, while the rookie Collins is 22.
The rest of the Cardinals’ young talent either hasn’t lived up to expectations or hasn’t had a chance to do anything yet.
13. Las Vegas Raiders
2020 ranking: 14
Blue-chip players: WR Henry Ruggs, ER Maxx Crosby, RB Josh Jacobs, SS Johnathan Abram, OT Alex Leatherwood
Notable graduated players: OT Kolton Miller, WR Hunter Renfrow
The Las Vegas roster is still showing the effects of the 2018 Khalil Mack trade. The Raiders have had six first-round picks over the past three seasons. The young talent on this team would be even more impressive if all of those players were still starting.
14. Minnesota Vikings
2020 ranking: 31
Blue-chip players: WR Justin Jefferson, CB Cameron Dantzler, OT Christian Darrisaw
Notable graduated players: OT Brian O’Neill
Wide receiver Justin Jefferson just turned 22 this past June and is the most valuable young offensive asset in the league other than the young quarterbacks.
15. Buffalo Bills
2020 ranking: 4
Blue-chip players: LB Tremaine Edmunds, DT Ed Oliver, WR Gabriel Davis
Notable graduated players: QB Josh Allen, CB Taron Johnson
Josh Allen turned 25 in May, which is a big reason the Bills take a tumble in the under-25 talent rankings. But there’s still a good amount of young talent at other positions.
16. Chicago Bears
2020 ranking: 26
Blue-chip players: QB Justin Fields, LB Roquan Smith, CB Jaylon Johnson
Notable graduated players: None
The Bears have good young talent on both sides of the ball, although the defensive talent is more proven than the offensive talent. The defense is led by linebacker Roquan Smith, still just 24 years old after three years in the league. The offensive side of the ball is more about unmet potential, but there’s a lot of it here.
17. Denver Broncos
2020 ranking: 18
Blue-chip players: WR Jerry Jeudy, QB Drew Lock, C Lloyd Cushenberry, CB Patrick Surtain, TE Noah Fant
Notable graduated players: ER Bradley Chubb, WR Courtland Sutton
Denver didn’t have anybody at the top when we ranked young players according to future value, but it had five players between Nos. 40 and 120.
18. Pittsburgh Steelers
2020 ranking: 6
Blue-chip players: FS Minkah Fitzpatrick, LB Devin Bush, WR Chase Claypool, WR JuJu Smith-Schuster
Notable graduated players: WR Diontae Johnson
Pittsburgh led the NFL in defensive DVOA last season, so it’s no surprise that its young talent base is highlighted by defensive players. The Steelers just wish they had them under contract for a bit longer. On offense, the top asset is 23-year-old wide receiver Chase Claypool.
19. Tennessee Titans
2020 ranking: 13
Blue-chip players: WR A.J. Brown, DL Jeffery Simmons, G Nate Davis
Notable graduated players: LB Rashaan Evans, ER Harold Landry
Here’s another team where the most outstanding young talent is a year from falling out of consideration for this ranking. Wide receiver A.J. Brown is a yards-after-catch machine, and finished fourth and eighth in DVOA among wide receivers in his first two NFL seasons. Defensive lineman Jeffery Simmons had 21 hurries last season, an outstanding total for a 5-tech in a 3-4 base defense. Guard Nate Davis is a premier road-grader in the running game, although he could stand to take another step forward in pass protection. All three players are 24 years old.
20. Dallas Cowboys
2020 ranking: 24
Blue-chip players: WR CeeDee Lamb, CB Trevon Diggs, LB Micah Parsons
Notable graduated players: LB Leighton Vander Esch, WR Michael Gallup
The best young asset on the Cowboys’ roster is wide receiver CeeDee Lamb, who amassed 935 yards and five touchdowns as a rookie.
The defensive talent is highlighted by this year’s first-round pick, 22-year-old linebacker Micah Parsons.
21. Atlanta Falcons
2020 ranking: 30
Blue-chip players: CB A.J. Terrell, G Chris Lindstrom, TE Kyle Pitts
Notable graduated players: None
Atlanta fans can certainly argue with this ranking based on how much they want to value 20-year-old tight end Kyle Pitts. The value calculations that start off this ranking are somewhat conservative about rookies, because many of them do not have a ton of value in their first season or two.
22. Cleveland Browns
2020 ranking: 9
Blue-chip players: OT Jedrick Wills, CB Denzel Ward, CB Greg Newsome
Notable graduated players: ER Myles Garrett, RB Nick Chubb
Cleveland ranks a bit lower than you might expect because injuries have kept us from seeing what some of its young players can do.
23. Detroit Lions
2020 ranking: 25
Blue-chip players: TE T.J. Hockenson, G Jonah Jackson, CB Jeff Okudah, OT Penei Sewell
Notable graduated players: C Frank Ragnow, CB Amani Oruwariye
The young talent in Detroit is built around three straight top-eight draft selections.
The top 2019 pick, 24-year-old tight end T.J. Hockenson, still hasn’t put up above-average DVOA through two years, but he did have 723 yards and six touchdowns last season while his blocking improved. The top 2020 pick, 22-year-old cornerback Jeff Okudah, underwhelmed with a miserable 36% coverage success rate and 11.9 yards allowed per pass as a rookie, but all that potential he showed in college is still brimming under the surface. The top 2021 pick, offensive tackle Penei Sewell, is still just 20 years old and is one of the most promising young tackle prospects in years. He won’t turn 21 until October.
24. Green Bay Packers
2020 ranking: 22
Blue-chip players: CB Jaire Alexander, SS Darnell Savage, QB Jordan Love
Notable graduated players: G Elgton Jenkins
Jaire Alexander is still just 24 years old and the best young cornerback in the game. \
On offense, 23-year-old running back AJ Dillon could get more playing time in his second year. Oh, and there’s a 22-year-old quarterback prospect named Jordan Love around here somewhere. But who knows when that guy’s ever going to get a chance to play.
25. Philadelphia Eagles
2020 ranking: 29
Blue-chip players: WR Jalen Reagor, WR DeVonta Smith, QB Jalen Hurts
Notable graduated players: ER Derek Barnett
Philadelphia’s young talent starts with the “skill position” players, but a couple of those players definitely need to show more production in their second seasons.
26. New Orleans Saints
2020 ranking: 21
Blue-chip players: G Cesar Ruiz, C Erik McCoy, ER Payton Turner
Notable graduated players: CB Marshon Lattimore
27. Seattle Seahawks
2020 ranking: 28
Blue-chip players: WR DK Metcalf, G Damien Lewis
Notable graduated players: SS Jamal Adams, ER L.J. Collier, DT Poona Ford
Wide receiver DK Metcalf is of course a complete dynamo, finishing fifth in receiving DYAR last season with 1,303 receiving yards and 10 touchdowns. He turns 24 in December.
This gets at the general issue for the Seahawks, which is that their young talent base doesn’t have many players below age 23.
28. Indianapolis Colts
2020 ranking: 15
Blue-chip players: RB Jonathan Taylor, ER Kwity Paye
Notable graduated players: G Quenton Nelson, OT Braden Smith, SS Khari Willis, CB Rock Ya-Sin
A lack of recent first-round picks knocks down the Colts in this ranking of under-25 talent, as does the fact that they had so many top players (especially those two offensive linemen) turn 25 in the past 12 months.
29. Kansas City Chiefs
2020 ranking: 11
Blue-chip players: RB Clyde Edwards-Helaire
Notable graduated players: QB Patrick Mahomes, FS Juan Thornhill, DT Derrick Nnadi
When the best player in the game turns 25, you’re going to drop in a ranking of under-25 talent. That’s exactly what happens with Kansas City now that Patrick Mahomes has aged out of this ranking. He does leave behind a few talented young players, but nobody who has yet to start 16 games in a season.
30. New England Patriots
2020 ranking: 32
Blue-chip players: QB Mac Jones, OL Michael Onwenu
Notable graduated players: OT Isaiah Wynn, DT Byron Cowart, SS Kyle Dugger, CB J.C. Jackson
Mac Jones is the future of the Patriots and he’s just 22 years old; he’s clearly their most important young asset. After Jones, the best young asset here is one of last year’s big surprises: 23-year-old offensive lineman Michael Onwenu. The sixth-round rookie played all across the line. Ranked at right tackle, his most common position, he comes out sixth in snaps per blown block. He’ll replace Joe Thuney at left guard this year.
The Patriots rank lower in under-25 talent in part because they tend to redshirt rookies, which means there are a lot of players floating around here who haven’t done much yet but still have potential.
31. Los Angeles Rams
2020 ranking: 27
Blue-chip players: SS Jordan Fuller
Notable graduated players: G Austin Corbett
It’s hard to rank high in under-25 talent when you go seven years without a first-round pick
32. Houston Texans
2020 ranking: 10
Blue-chip players: None
Notable graduated players: QB Deshaun Watson, OT Tytus Howard, G Max Scharping
Looking at the past four drafts demonstrates why the Texans are in last place in our ranking of under-25 talent.
From the 2019 draft, first-round pick Tytus Howard is now 25. The Texans had two second-round picks, Max Scharping and Lonnie Johnson. They are both now 25. The third-round pick, tight end Kahale Warring, is still 24 but didn’t see the field in his first two seasons and now has a grand total of three career receptions.
In the 2020 draft, the Texans had no first-round pick due to the Laremy Tunsil trade. Second-round defensive tackle Ross Blacklock is now 23; he missed his first season and couldn’t break into the starting lineup in his second season. Third-round edge rusher Jonathan Greenard is 24 and played only 265 defensive snaps last year with one sack and three hurries.
In the 2021 draft, the Texans had no first- or second-round pick, again due to the Tunsil trade. That means their young rookie talent is highlighted by a couple of third-round picks, quarterback Davis Mills and wide receiver Nico Collins. Both are 22 years old.
We should also mention safety Justin Reid, who hasn’t played up to his potential in recent years because of injuries. Reid, now 24 years old, was the Texans’ highest pick in 2018 as a third-round selection. They didn’t have a first- or second-round pick that year either.
This roster is not in good shape.
|