TEAM DRAFT
Not quite a traditional Mock, but Mel Kiper, Jr. and Todd McShay of ESPN.com drafted competing full teams from the Class of 2021.
Two NFL draft analysts, 22 rounds, 44 total picks: Mel Kiper Jr. and Todd McShay went head-to-head to draft their own superteams of the best 2021 prospects.
The rules? Kiper and McShay alternated picks to fill out starting lineups, with each roster having 11 starters on both offense and defense. (Sorry, fans of special teams.) They were allowed to draft positions in any order, and they designed their units around whatever scheme they wanted to run on each side of the ball. Versatility was a must for both teams. They drafted all 44 picks live on the First Draft podcast Tuesday and debated their choices along the way.
Which team has the edge at quarterback, wide receiver, pass-rusher and cornerback? Let’s start at the top and go pick by pick, ending with what Kiper and McShay think of their teams. Field Yates, who hosts the podcast, was the neutral observer, and he picked his favorite team, as well. Jump to the end to see the complete rosters.
Mel Kiper: I was looking at my team from last year, Todd, and I have to say that I crushed you. Justin Jefferson and Tee Higgins catching passes from Joe Burrow, who was protected at tackle by Mekhi Becton and Jedrick Wills Jr.
Todd McShay: Crushed me? Mel, Chase Young — the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year — would have been all over Burrow in the pocket. And the press coverage from my guys Trevon Diggs and Jaylon Johnson would have been a problem for you.
Kiper: My tackles wouldn’t have let Young touch Burrow, and he’d get the ball out quickly anyway. Jefferson would have 14 catches for 204 yards and three touchdowns against your defense.
McShay: Either way, I’m not sure you had the defense to slow down CeeDee Lamb, Brandon Aiyuk, Henry Ruggs III, Jerry Jeudy and D’Andre Swift in space. But I admit, I’m still mad you stole Antoine Winfield Jr. from me in the middle picks.
Kiper: OK, losing team picks first. You’re up.
McShay: You might regret that; this isn’t the year to give up the top pick.
No. 1 pick, McShay: Trevor Lawrence, QB, Clemson
McShay: I win, right? Lawrence is the best quarterback prospect I’ve seen in a decade. How are you going to stop him, Mel? What’s your plan here?
No. 2 pick, Kiper: Kyle Pitts, TE, Florida
Kiper: You know, I’m going to follow some advice from a draft consultant here. There’s no reason I need to take my quarterback now. I’ll get him at the end. We don’t build one-man teams.
Pitts is the best available prospect on my board. I’ve never given a tight end as high a grade as I have for Pitts, and I’ve been doing this for more than 40 years. He is a special talent.
No. 3 pick, McShay: Ja’Marr Chase, WR, LSU
McShay: I love Pitts too, but I’m happy getting my No. 1-ranked wide receiver in Chase. He is physical, he has speed, and his body control is outstanding.
No. 4 pick, Kiper: DeVonta Smith, WR, Alabama
Kiper: That’s OK, because I have Smith slightly ahead of Chase anyway, so I’m getting my top-ranked wideout.
McShay: Why do you like Smith over Chase, Mel?
Kiper: It’s extremely close, and they both have superstar potential, but Smith is a better route runner — he is so smooth — and knows how to get open, whereas Chase still has a ways to go as a consistent route runner. Chase caught a lot of deep balls in 2019, but he also had a pinpoint passer throwing to him in Burrow. Chase might not have that right away in the NFL. Smith’s game translates extremely well.
No. 5 pick, McShay: Penei Sewell, OT, Oregon
McShay: You were doing a lot of talking earlier about your Burrow-Jefferson connection behind your great offensive line, but now you’re letting me have Lawrence throw to Chase behind Sewell? Sewell has great length, power and quickness, especially for a 6-foot-6, 330-pound tackle.
No. 6 pick, Kiper: Jaylen Waddle, WR, Alabama
Kiper: So that’s Pitts, Smith and Waddle as my top weapons so far, and three of my top five prospects overall. Waddle is my deep threat. He can play with his Crimson Tide teammate in Smith. Do I even need a quarterback with the offense I’m building? You can be my quarterback, Todd.
No. 7 pick, McShay: Micah Parsons, ILB, Penn State
McShay: With the top four pass-catchers gone, and with my roster set at quarterback and left tackle, I think it’s finally time to get the first defender off the board.
Kiper: This draft is shaping up like how I expect it to on April 29. It should be all offense at the top. Teams will be able to get good defenders — not great ones — late in Round 1 and on Day 2. There just isn’t much elite defensive talent in this class.
McShay: Agree — but Parsons is one of those elites. He does it all, dropping into coverage, disrupting as a run defender and even showing burst as a pass-rusher.
No. 8 pick, Kiper: Rashawn Slater, OT, Northwestern
Kiper: I’ll keep waiting on defense. Slater is my left tackle. He is a complete player. You think he also could start at guard or center, right, Todd?
McShay: He doesn’t have prototypical tackle length, and he could kick inside because of it. But with his balance and foot speed, he is a tackle in the NFL. That’s a good pick.
Kiper: Glad you finally like one of my picks.
No. 9 pick, McShay: Patrick Surtain II, CB, Alabama
McShay: I’ll just keep taking the top-ranked players at key positions. I already have that box checked for quarterback, wide receiver, offensive tackle and linebacker. And Surtain is the best corner. I love his instincts, and he is the kind of shutdown CB you can rely on. Plus, he had plenty of practice reps in Tuscaloosa facing your guys Smith and Waddle.
No. 10 pick, Kiper: Alijah Vera-Tucker, G, USC
Kiper: I’ll put Vera-Tucker at either guard or right tackle, depending on how the rest of this draft shakes out. He is a mauler in the run game. I love my offense so far.
No. 11 pick, McShay: Kadarius Toney, WR, Florida
McShay: Toney is dangerous in space, and I’ll get him going with plenty of screens, sweeps and quick-game throws early, before unleashing some vertical shots to him.
Kiper: Nice pick, Todd. Toney is a great fit with Chase and Lawrence.
McShay: If I can’t have Waddle, I have to have Toney. I can lean on him in the return game, too. He is a versatile weapon.
No. 12 pick, Kiper: Jamin Davis, ILB, Kentucky
Kiper: OK, here we go with a defender. Davis is the leader and signal-caller of my D. He is a playmaker who flies to the football.
McShay: Really, Mel? Davis is my guy. You’re welcome for the heads-up on him.
Kiper: Hey, you had your chance, and you took Parsons. I can’t wait to watch Davis fill run fits and get tackles for loss at the next level.
No. 13 pick, McShay: Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah, OLB, Notre Dame
McShay: More versatility. Owusu-Koramoah is smooth, instinctive and fast, and I can use him as a weakside linebacker and in the overhang role. Having a guy like him on my team is going to allow me to play different styles on defense.
No. 14 pick, Kiper: Kwity Paye, DE, Michigan
Kiper: Time to address the pass rush. Paye is my top-ranked defensive end. He has big-time upside, even if he didn’t have the production in college. If he lands in the right spot at the next level, he’ll get 10 sacks a year.
No. 15 pick, McShay: Jaycee Horn, CB, South Carolina
McShay: Horn is an excellent press corner who tracks the ball well. The ball production isn’t there yet (two interceptions in 30 games), but it will come. I saw you load up on pass-catchers and knew I had to go get the top two corners.
Kiper: So you’re prioritizing cornerback over edge rusher? Interesting strategy.
McShay: I can get pass-rushers later. I have three corners ranked before my first edge rusher. Simply put, the top of the corner class is stronger than the top of the pass-rush class, and I wanted to capitalize.
No. 16 pick, Kiper: Jaelan Phillips, OLB, Miami (Fla.)
Kiper: So let me snag my other top-ranked defensive end. Phillips is the best pure pass-rusher in this class, an absolute menace off the line of scrimmage. If his medical reports check out — Phillips had multiple concussions at UCLA before he transferred to Miami — he could be a steal in the 18 to 25 range in the real draft.
No. 17 pick, McShay: Gregory Rousseau, DE, Miami (Fla.)
McShay: I’ll take another Miami pass-rusher — though Rousseau was never on the field at the same time as Phillips because Rousseau opted out in 2020. But Rousseau had 15.5 sacks in 2019, and though he needs a little refining, he has good bend and physical traits. And he has the ability to kick inside depending on how the rest of my team shapes up.
No. 18 pick, Kiper: Caleb Farley, CB, Virginia Tech
Kiper: I was surprised you went with Surtain and Horn over Farley, who is my top-ranked corner. Why is that, Todd?
McShay: Farley has had some issues with his back, including a surgery for a herniated disk last month. And because he opted out of the 2020 season, we haven’t seen him do much — even work out — in a long time. The cover skills are legit, but there’s just a little too much risk there when Surtain and Horn are also in the class.
Kiper: That’s fair. I’m taking the long-range view, though, because when Farley is healthy, he is the best true cover corner in this draft. He sticks to receivers.
No. 19 pick, McShay: Azeez Ojulari, OLB, Georgia
McShay: OK, we’re going with a hybrid 3-4/4-3 defense, and I’ve got Ojulari dipping and ripping off the edge. Good luck with that, Mel.
No. 20 pick, Kiper: Christian Darrisaw, OT, Virginia Tech
Kiper: Darrisaw will play right tackle for my team, and he’ll join his former Virginia Tech teammate Farley. I now have three of my top four offensive linemen, with Darrisaw and Slater at tackle and Vera-Tucker at guard.
No. 21 pick, McShay: Najee Harris, RB, Alabama
McShay: Harris is fantastic between the tackles, and I think he was much more decisive as a runner this past season. Man, this offense is going to be fun.
Kiper: So you agree with me that Harris has the edge over Clemson’s Travis Etienne? I’ll wait a little bit to take my running back.
McShay: Wait as long as you want. It’s close between the two, but if I’m drafting just one RB, I want the one who can rush, catch passes and pass protect as an every-down back. Etienne has an explosive second gear when he hits daylight, but I’m taking into consideration his heavy college workload and issues in pass pro.
No. 22 pick, Kiper: Trevon Moehrig, S. TCU
Kiper: Once again, this is a player who ranks No. 1 at his position on my board. He’ll be my center fielder, and he’ll keep a close eye on those deep throws from Lawrence.
McShay: We’re halfway done, Mel. I love what I got, but I’ll need to start building up that offensive line alongside Sewell. How are you feeling about your roster?
Kiper: My offense is loaded. We also have the advantage at head coach and general manager.
No. 23 pick, McShay: Teven Jenkins, OT, Oklahoma State
McShay: I need a big, physical tackle on the right side. Jenkins is going to be my mauler and help drive back defenders for Harris.
No. 24 pick, Kiper: Landon Dickerson, C, Alabama
Kiper: I’m a huge fan of Dickerson, who will be one of the leaders of my squad. That’s four of my five linemen set, and I’ll save my right guard spot for later.
No. 25 pick, McShay: Christian Barmore, DT, Alabama
McShay: Well, it’s pick No. 25, and this makes six Alabama players off the board. What a class for the Crimson Tide, yet again. And Barmore will help stop your run game up the middle.
No. 26 pick, Kiper: Zaven Collins, ILB, Tulsa
Kiper: My front seven is going to be about versatility, and Collins could play with his hand in the dirt at defensive end or at stand-up linebacker. He does it all. We’ll be fluid between a 3-4 and a 4-3 defense. We’ll keep Lawrence guessing.
No. 27 pick, McShay: Terrace Marshall Jr., WR, LSU
McShay: I got my WR1 in Chase outside. I got my versatile, elusive slot receiver in Toney. Now I’m getting a big target for Lawrence to find in the end zone. Marshall has 23 TDs over the past two seasons, and he has unique speed for his 6-foot-3 frame.
No. 28 pick, Kiper: Richie Grant, S, UCF
Kiper: You still haven’t taken a safety? I now have the top two in my rankings. And Moehrig and Grant fit well playing beside each other.
McShay: I admit that I wanted Moehrig, but I have a few guys ranked higher than Grant. I’m not worried.
Kiper: Grant is really good. He had 10 picks and six forced fumbles in his career. He could be a Round 2 steal later this month.
No. 29 pick, McShay: Liam Eichenberg, G, Notre Dame
McShay: I’d have to reach a bit for a true center or guard, so I’m taking Eichenberg and sliding him inside to left guard. He is an excellent pass-protector, and he has the versatility to play on the interior for me.
No. 30 pick, Kiper: Rashod Bateman, WR, Minnesota
Kiper: I was looking for a big wideout to play with Smith and Waddle, and Bateman fits the bill. He is physical and will pick up first downs. He’ll break tackles after the catch.
No. 31 pick, McShay: Carlos Basham Jr., DE, Wake Forest
McShay: I’m going with power for my ends, pairing Basham with Rousseau. They’ll overwhelm your tackles. And don’t forget, I’ll have Ojulari crashing down on your QB too.
Kiper: I do like this pick, though “Boogie” Basham was better as a junior in 2019 than he was last season. He had 11 sacks and 18 total tackles for loss that year. I put him at No. 11 overall on my preseason Big Board. He has some potential.
McShay: Basham is probably second-rounder. I had him going to the New York Giants at No. 42 in my recent two-round mock draft. But he is an effective pass-rusher and also can bump inside if I need him to in my scheme.
No. 32 pick, Kiper: Greg Newsome II, CB, Northwestern
Kiper: Newsome is rising after a terrific 2020 season. I put him at No. 29 to the Green Bay Packers in my Mock Draft 3.0. He could play in any system.
No. 33 pick, McShay: Levi Onwuzurike, DT, Washington
McShay: This completes my front seven, and I really like that stout run defense. With Barmore and Onwuzurike down the middle — along with Parsons and Owusu-Koramoah at the second level — I hope you aren’t trying to go north-south with the run game, Mel. Speaking of which, who’s your tailback?
No. 34 pick, Kiper: Travis Etienne, RB, Clemson
Kiper: OK, I need to start filling out the rest of my roster. I need a running back, an offensive lineman, three front-seven pieces and, of course, my quarterback. We’ll start with Etienne, who could sneak into Round 1 later this month. He is a home run hitter. I have Harris ranked higher, but Etienne is a great player too.
No. 35 pick, McShay: Creed Humphrey, C, Oklahoma
McShay: Humphrey is a former high school wrestler, and the 6-foot-4, 302-pounder wins with his hand fighting. But don’t discount his speed and explosiveness, which were on display at his pro day.
No. 36 pick, Kiper: Samuel Cosmi, G, Texas
Kiper: How about Red River rivals back to back here? I’ll put Cosmi at right guard. He played left tackle in college, but I think he could move inside in the NFL. He has some power to his game.
No. 37 pick, McShay: Quinn Meinerz, RG, Wisconsin-Whitewater
McShay: Sticking to the board here, Meinerz is my best available interior player. That finishes up the line. Just safety and tight end left to worry about, and with you set at both positions, I’m already eyeing my guys.
No. 38 pick, Kiper: Ronnie Perkins, OLB, Oklahoma
Kiper: Perkins is another versatile edge defender. He weighed 253 pounds at his pro day, but he could slim down a little bit and play outside linebacker for my squad. Just using my rankings as a guide, though, I have three of my top four defensive ends. We’re going to beat up the quarterback.
No. 39 pick, McShay: Andre Cisco, S, Syracuse
McShay: Cisco is a rangy ball hawk who will generate turnovers for my team. He had 13 interceptions over his three-year career at Syracuse. And turnovers mean more offensive possessions for Lawrence & Co.
No. 40 pick, Kiper: Milton Williams, DE, Louisiana Tech
Kiper: I’m reaching a little bit here, but I need a big end if I’m going to run a 3-4, and Williams weighed 284 pounds at his pro day last month. He could play 5-technique in a 3-4 or as a 3-technique in a 4-3. Where is he in your rankings, Todd?
McShay: Outside my top 100, at the moment. I know you want that big end, but Washington’s Joe Tryon, Penn State’s Jayson Oweh and Pittsburgh’s Patrick Jones II are still out there. And if you want size, what about Houston’s Payton Turner? I’m not sure I get this pick; it seems like a massive reach.
Kiper: This late in the draft, I broke my own rule and went for a fit over value. But you’re underrating Williams. He could go in the second round.
No. 41 pick, McShay: Pat Freiermuth, TE, Penn State
McShay: Well, I see you’re waiting until the end to take a QB after I took Lawrence first overall, so I did the same with tight end after you went with Pitts at No. 2. There’s obviously a dip here — I had Freiermuth at No. 45 to Jacksonville in my mock — but he is tough over the middle and is an effective blocker.
No. 42 pick, Kiper: Daviyon Nixon, DT, Iowa
Kiper: Nixon will be my nose tackle. He had an awesome 2020 season, with 5.5 sacks and a 71-yard pick-six. He moves really well for his size.
No. 43 pick, McShay: Jevon Holland, S, Oregon
McShay: One spot left, and I landed my second-ranked safety. He is physical and yet another ball hawk on the back end. Plus, he can drop in to line up over the slot. Which reminds me: Where are our nickel cornerbacks? We need to add that spot, because I really wanted to find a way to get Florida State’s Asante Samuel Jr. on my team.
No. 44 pick, Kiper: Justin Fields, QB, Ohio State
Kiper: Surprised that I picked Fields over Zach Wilson? You shouldn’t be. I’ve had Fields as my No. 2 quarterback all along, and I’m not changing now.
McShay: Wow. Still? There’s no way I’d go Fields over Wilson. I guess Fields beat Lawrence head-to-head in the College Football Playoff, but it isn’t happening again here. You’re getting the fourth- or fifth-best quarterback in the class to run your squad. I’ll give you a mulligan if you want, Mel.
Kiper: I feel really good about my team. I have an elite offensive line and four spectacular pass-catchers. My defense is physical and versatile, and I have both of my top-ranked corners. I think Las Vegas would make me at least a seven-point favorite on a neutral field. Let’s line up these teams across from each other.
McShay: Are you kidding? The starting point is about -3 for me with Lawrence at QB, and then it only continues to grow in my favor. I have my No. 1-ranked QB, RB, WR, OT, C, ILB, DT and CB. Lawrence and Chase are going to tear up your secondary, and Harris is going to run all over your front seven. Who is playing defensive tackle for you, Mel?
Kiper: There’s no Aaron Donald in this class. Why are we worrying about defensive tackle? I trust my rankings.
McShay: All I know is if Surtain and Horn will play press on your receivers all day and take away Fields’ first reads. When do I get my championship trophy?
Kiper: No way. Field, you’re with me on this, right?
Field Yates: Ultimately, the NFL is, and largely always has been, a quarterback-driven league. And while I am as strong of a Fields backer as there is, Lawrence profiles as the most can’t-miss prospect at the position since Andrew Luck back in 2012. Couple Lawrence under center with the multiplicity that GM McShay has created on defense — with the likes of Parsons, Owusu-Koramoah and Ojulari among his ‘backers — and this team gains the narrowest of edges. Mel, I promise it’s not personal!
The All-Draft Prospect Teams
POSITION TODD MCSHAY MEL KIPER
QB Trevor Lawrence (1) Justin Fields (44)
RB Najee Harris (21) Travis Etienne (34)
WR Ja’Marr Chase (3) DeVonta Smith (4)
WR Kadarius Toney (11) Jaylen Waddle (6)
WR Terrace Marshall Jr. (27) Rashod Bateman (30)
TE Pat Freiermuth (41) Kyle Pitts (2)
LT Penei Sewell (5) Rashawn Slater (8)
LG Liam Eichenberg (29) Alijah Vera-Tucker (10)
C Creed Humphrey (35) Landon Dickerson (24)
RG Quinn Meinerz (37) Samuel Cosmi (36)
RT Teven Jenkins (23) Christian Darrisaw (20)
DE/OLB Gregory Rousseau (17) Kwity Paye (14)
DT Levi Onwuzurike (33) Daviyon Nixon (42)
DT/DE Christian Barmore (25) Milton Williams (40)
DE/OLB Carlos Basham Jr. (31) Jaelan Phillips (16)
LB Azeez Ojulari (19) Jamin Davis (12)
LB Micah Parsons (7) Zaven Collins (26)
LB J. Owusu-Koramoah (13) Ronnie Perkins (38)
CB Patrick Surtain II (9) Caleb Farley (18)
CB Jaycee Horn (15) Greg Newsome II (32)
S Andre Cisco (39) Trevon Moehrig (22)
S Jevon Holland (43) Richie Grant (28)
|