THE QBs OF 2021
Here is an interesting exercise as Field Yates of ESPN.com predicts who will be the QBs when the carousel stops. He starts with the teams he is most sure of and works down:
Kansas City Chiefs
Projected 2021 starter: Patrick Mahomes
I tried to type words to adequately describe Mahomes, and I couldn’t come up with anything. He’ll be back for the Chiefs.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Projected 2021 starter: Tom Brady
I feel like this guy has a future in football. Brady, who will turn 44 in August, is having a minor knee surgery this offseason, but he has already said he’s returning for his 22nd NFL season.
Green Bay Packers
Projected 2021 starter: Aaron Rodgers
The Packers are adamant about not trading Rodgers, which is logical given that he’s the reigning league MVP. He described his future following the season as a “beautiful mystery,” but a raise on the remaining three years of his current deal feels far more likely than a trade.
Seattle Seahawks
Projected 2021 starter: Russell Wilson
Since being drafted by Seattle in 2012, Wilson has missed precisely zero starts for the Seahawks. He’s an amazing player. That streak will continue, even if he’s frustrated with the organization.
Buffalo Bills
Projected 2021 starter: Josh Allen
After an ascendant 2020 campaign in which he threw 37 touchdown passes and completed 69.2% of his throws, Allen could make an MVP push in 2021.
Baltimore Ravens
Projected 2021 starter: Lamar Jackson
Jackson’s strong finish to the season was another signal that there are even more levels to his game ahead. The 2019 MVP has combined for 76 total touchdowns and 15 interceptions over the past two seasons.
Arizona Cardinals
Projected 2021 starter: Kyler Murray
Murray flirted with an MVP-type season for the first half of 2020 before fading down the stretch, as the Cardinals lost five of their final seven games. He should be even more lethal next season.
Tennessee Titans
Projected 2021 starter: Ryan Tannehill
Some people were skeptical that Tannehill could keep up his strong finish from 2019 into the 2020 season. Some people were wrong. He finished fourth in the league in Total QBR (78.3).
Los Angeles Chargers
Projected 2021 starter: Justin Herbert
The rookie Herbert took over as a surprise starter in Week 2 and kept the job the rest of the season, throwing 31 touchdown passes and just six picks. He could keep this job well past Week 2 of 2030.
Cleveland Browns
Projected 2021 starter: Baker Mayfield
Mayfield’s best season yet — he threw 26 touchdown passes and cut down on his turnovers on the way to the Browns winning a playoff game — could lead to a contract extension this offseason. He has already earned tons of respect in Cleveland.
Dallas Cowboys
Projected 2021 starter: Dak Prescott
The third round of negotiations is the charm for Dallas and Prescott, as I suspect the free agent winds up with a long-term deal this offseason, even if a franchise tag comes first to buy extra time. If Prescott plays on the franchise tag for the second consecutive year, he’ll make $37.7 million.
Cincinnati Bengals
Projected 2021 starter: Joe Burrow
The only way Burrow isn’t the Bengals’ Week 1 starter is if his surgically repaired knee requires more time to be ready for the season, but all indications suggest he’ll be ready to rock. The No. 1 pick in the 2020 draft tore the ACL and MCL in his left knee in late November.
Atlanta Falcons
Projected 2021 starter: Matt Ryan
It wouldn’t be shocking to see the Falcons use the fourth overall pick in April’s draft on a quarterback, as they must evaluate the opportunity cost; they don’t plan on picking this high again in the near future, and Ryan is about to turn 36. Passing on a quarterback now might mean squandering their best chance at a topflight prospect at any point over the next few years.
Ryan, however, remains a solid starter who is still owed a substantial amount of money, making a trade not palatable just from a financial standpoint (separate and apart from the Falcons not likely wanting to deal him).
Pittsburgh Steelers
Projected 2021 starter: Ben Roethlisberger
Roethlisberger has already conceded that he’s prepared to restructure his contract, as his $41.25 million salary-cap hit is not viable during a year in which the cap could hover around $180 million. How much of a pay reduction he takes is to be determined, but that doesn’t change the fact that he’s in line to start again.
Minnesota Vikings
Projected 2021 starter: Kirk Cousins
Cousins’ future has generated conversation for about five of the past six offseasons, but I really do take the Vikings at face value when they state their support of him for 2021. He’s a solid starter, and the Vikings likely feel internally that fixing their defense will go a long way toward pushing them back to the playoffs in 2021.
Las Vegas Raiders
Projected 2021 starter: Derek Carr
It feels like we’ve been wondering whether Carr’s time was over with the Raiders since coach Jon Gruden was hired, but the veteran has been a mainstay. He is one of those quarterbacks who threads a unique needle: He has moments of excellence that inspire confidence and rarely has abomination games that cost the team, but it still feels like we’re debating his status as the franchise’s future annually. With two years left on his current contract, it’s likely that Carr is back again.
San Francisco 49ers
Projected 2021 starter: Jimmy Garoppolo
This is an interesting one. Jimmy G has been a part of a 49ers team that has won a ton of games with him under center, yet this still feels like a much less than 100% certain scenario. His contract is at the juncture in which the team can get out from it without major financial penalty — it could trade or release him and save more than $23 million.
With the quarterback carousel spinning, everyone wants to connect Kyle Shanahan to any of the available options. But there has been enough messaging from the team lately to make me believe Garoppolo is the man for one more season (or more).
Philadelphia Eagles
Projected 2021 starter: Jalen Hurts
Hurts was the player I wasn’t sure whether to classify as a new or returning starter, as he started only the final four games for Philly in 2020. Alas, we’ll call him a returning starter with Carson Wentz now almost certain to be traded soon.
Hurts infused energy into Philly’s offense and an added element of rushing — he had 238 rushing yards in his three full games as the starter — with the usual strides to make for any young quarterback; his accuracy will improve after he completed just 52% of his passes last season.
Miami Dolphins
Projected 2021 starter: Tua Tagovailoa
Until Deshaun Watson is traded, many people will link Miami as a most logical suitor. For now, I believe Tagovailoa returns as the starter, with Miami instead focusing on surrounding him with elevated talent to allow him to grow. After all, he’s just a year removed from being the No. 5 overall pick in the draft.
Tagovailoa had his moments as a rookie starter, and he has plenty of natural tools with which to work. Ultimately, he’ll face unique expectations given his draft status, but Year 2 should look much better.
New York Giants
Projected 2021 starter: Daniel Jones
If this decision were cast in the court of public opinion, many would suggest the Giants ought to be digging into the quarterback market this offseason. However, there has been nary a whisper so far about the G-Men shopping for a signal-caller. (Yes, I know it’s early.)
While he is at times erratic and turnover-prone, the organization has a lot of investment in Jones’ development. There’s still potential here.
Denver Broncos
Projected 2021 starter: Drew Lock
New general manager George Paton brings a fresh set of eyes, with the most pressing question being whether Lock is a centerpiece of the franchise or the latest in a long line of Broncos quarterbacks on the merry-go-round of starters.
Turnovers and accuracy were both issues last season for Lock — and Denver reportedly sniffed around on a Matthew Stafford trade — so my confidence level isn’t significant here. But while we are recent witnesses to instant-impact rookie star quarterbacks, investing in a young player who has early struggles can pay off in a decided way if you have implicit belief in the skill set. I’ll bet on that in Denver.
TEAMS WITH NEW STARTERS
I’m forecasting 21 teams to keep their starters from 2021, which means there are 11 more to go. Let’s start with two locks at the top and get into the mysteries after that.
Los Angeles Rams
Projected 2021 starter: Matthew Stafford
While this move can’t be made official until the start of the new league year, the Rams are ready to push their chips back into the middle of the table with Stafford under center. The internal expectations have to be to make a Super Bowl run soon, given the steep price paid to acquire Stafford.
Detroit Lions
Projected 2021 starter: Jared Goff
I find it interesting that sometimes when a quarterback isn’t a surefire franchise-level-type player, we decry him as little more than a spare part. Is Goff one of the 10 or so best quarterbacks in the league? No. Is he a capable starter whom the Lions can turn to for a bridge season or two? He certainly is.
Jacksonville Jaguars
Projected 2021 starter: Trevor Lawrence
Losing is not a spearhead for success in the NFL, but the Jaguars are incredibly fortunate to have the opportunity to draft the prodigious Lawrence. Jacksonville has the No. 1 overall pick, and Lawrence is seen by many as the top QB prospect to come out of college in nearly a decade. Now, the Jaguars must right the ship around him. New coach Urban Meyer will help immensely.
New Orleans Saints
Projected 2021 starter: Jameis Winston
With Drew Brees’ retirement announcement imminent, the Saints will have to turn to a new full-time starter for the first time in what feels like forever. While Taysom Hill was the player to fill in for Brees this past season, Winston is a part of the team’s plans for 2021, per head coach Sean Payton, and there’s reason to believe the team will feel more comfortable with him heading into 2021 than it did when Brees got hurt last year. With more time to develop and build chemistry, Winston has a chance to revitalize his career. He’s a free agent, but we suspect he’ll get signed.
Carolina Panthers
Projected 2021 starter: Deshaun Watson
I’ve been on record forecasting Watson to Miami, but recently my tenor has changed with more support from the Dolphins for Tua Tagovailoa and the Panthers’ previous aggressive pursuit of Matthew Stafford. Carolina’s roster on defense took shape relatively quickly in 2020, opening its window to be aggressive sooner. New GM Scott Fitterer has the eighth pick as one of his chips to play in a deal to acquire Watson.
Houston has no interest in trading him away right now, but we know this has already been ugly. If you ultimately trade away a franchise quarterback, moving him to a team you play once every four years is preferred to an in-conference foe (assuming the offers are comparable).
Indianapolis Colts
Projected 2021 starter: Carson Wentz
There’s been plenty of smoke surrounding the Colts and Bears as landing spots for Wentz, as Indy would reunite him with Frank Reich, his former offensive coordinator. The Colts’ roster is ready to win right now, so entering the season with a rookie or otherwise unproven starter would be potentially missing out on a window to compete.
Wentz is radioactive at the moment after his dismal 2020 performance. Can Reich and his staff reconstruct the player who was once ascendant enough to earn a record-setting contract extension that no one questioned the Eagles for giving him? Count me among those who believe in Indy’s infrastructure.
New England Patriots
Projected 2021 starter: Marcus Mariota
The Patriots are among a group of teams that are too far from the top of the draft order to be a likely landing spot for the top-draft-prospect quarterbacks, meaning we’re examining other veteran options who could be logical fits. While a Cam Newton return isn’t totally ruled out, it’s an unlikely option. The 27-year-old Mariota is under contract for one more year with the Raiders but carries a cap charge of $10.725M, an unlikely tab for them to pay for a backup in a cap-tightened year.
Be it via a trade or cut, Mariota could find a new home this offseason … and the Patriots are a logical fit.
Washington Football Team
Projected 2021 starter: Ryan Fitzpatrick
Washington is in the same category as the Patriots: in need of a quarterback addition but too far down the draft order to count on that as the avenue to address it. Fitzy is about as well-traveled as any other player in the league over the past 15 years, but he continues to play at a strong enough level to merit starting consideration. It’s often a roller coaster with him under center, but he has an infectious energy that cannot be discounted. We saw it last year in Miami when he helped the team in a few gotta-have-it situations.
Houston Texans
Projected 2021 starter: Justin Fields
Having already accounted for a Deshaun Watson trade, we need to find his heir apparent. While I do not believe Fields will be available at No. 8 in the draft — a key part of any Watson-to-Carolina trade — Houston would at least have additional capital to move further up the board to select Fields, the Ohio State standout who could be the second quarterback off the board. Parting ways with Watson will be an exorbitantly tough pill to swallow, but Fields is the beacon of light toward the future that the Texans will need.
New York Jets
Projected 2021 starter: Zach Wilson
The Jets could build around Sam Darnold using the trove of draft picks they have both this year and next, but committing to him on the fifth-year option this offseason (which fully guarantees somewhere around $25M in 2022) is a heavier-handed investment than the team likely wants to make after an uneven start to his career.
The Jets must also evaluate the opportunity cost. The team is hopeful and believes a turnaround is coming soon, meaning a pick this high in the draft won’t be a certainty going forward. If they pass on a young quarterback now, and Darnold is not the long-term answer, the Jets’ avenue to quarterback stability is harder to find. And Wilson could be special.
Chicago Bears
Projected 2021 starter: Sam Darnold
Part 2 of the Jets prediction is what happens to Darnold. The Bears need to win right away or organizational changes seem imminent, and while Darnold has much to prove, he has supporters within the NFL that could create a trade market.
Why would Chicago be willing to commit to Darnold in a trade and (likely) a fifth-year option when the Jets wouldn’t? Simple. Bears GM Ryan Pace has to be much more focused on 2021 than life beyond it. Darnold represents a likely upgrade over what the Bears have in place, and there’s certainly a chance he could rise under different circumstances than what he had in New York. But honestly, it’s hard to peg the Bears’ next starter.
Even if you think QB RUSSELL WILSON isn’t going anywhere, don’t you have to put his certainty of being a Seahawk below some others like QB JUSTIN HERBERT of the Chargers?
|