2023 DRAFT
Mike Renner of ProFootballFocus on the conundrum presented by QB WILL LEVIS – a first round prospect who couldn’t start at Penn State.
If there’s anything certain in the NFL’s evaluation of quarterbacks in recent years, it’s that most are going to get it wrong. Of the 12 quarterbacks selected in the top three of an NFL draft over the past decade, only four are locks to be starters in Week 1 next season.
Evaluating quarterbacks properly is simultaneously the most important thing in the sport and the most difficult.
Maybe it’s because of the nature of the position; no one thing guarantees success at the next level. Bill Parcells’ checklist of must-haves when evaluating a quarterback prospect is one of the most widespread sets of guidelines in the scouting world. But reading it now in the modern era? It’s almost comical.
Be a three-year starter
Be a senior in college
Graduate from college
Start 30 games
Win 23 games
Post a 2-1 touchdown-to-interception ratio
Complete at least 60% of passes thrown
Trevor Lawrence, Joe Burrow, Josh Allen, Kyler Murray, Lamar Jackson, Patrick Mahomes and Deshaun Watson all would have failed to go 7-for-7 and, in turn, been passed up by the Big Tuna.
So then what about those evaluating quarterbacks currently? Surely, there must be something that unites NFL personnel in a “must-have” on the path to success. Err … not quite. For Bill Belichick, it’s “make good decisions.” Former Pittsburgh Steelers general manager Kevin Colbert is on the record saying “accuracy.” Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers says quarterback prospects “have to be able to spin it,” referencing their arm strength.
It should be no surprise that properly assessing a complex position is, well, complex. But ultimately, the process of quarterback evaluation is no different than any other position. It comes down to how accurately you can answer the following questions:
Who are they?
What can they become?
What are their chances of getting there?
There’s no quarterback who will stress test scouts’ ability to answer those questions more at the quarterback position in the 2023 class than Kentucky’s Will Levis — the No. 2 signal-caller on PFF’s big board and the No. 3 prospect overall. He’s a 6-foot-3, 232-pound redshirt senior with a rocket launcher attached to his right shoulder. The Wildcats’ pro day isn’t until later this spring, but I can already, without a shred of doubt, say he’ll receive hype from every media outlet afterward for his performance. I mean, just look at these throws: (video not attached here)
And how well he can move at his size: (video not attached here)
His pros and cons list below doesn’t read too dissimilarly to that of Josh Allen coming out of Wyoming:
Pros
Flamethrower right arm
Ideal build that can take a hit
Twitchy mover in pocket
Will stand in and deliver strikes under pressure (9.2 yards per attempt under pressure in 2022)
Elite QB-sneaker. Converted 22-of-23 sneaks in career
Cons
Spotty accuracy
One-speed thrower
Will likely always struggle on touch passes with short-arm delivery
Bad habit of trying to do too much and forces throws
Unfortunately, that reads like a lot of athletic projects at the quarterback position in the draft. And for every Josh Allen, there’s a Jake Locker at home watching games on Sundays. It’s why the NFL still prefers those with high-end on-field production toward the top of the draft.
That’s where Levis falls considerably short (as everyone on Twitter will remind you when his name is brought up). There’s no sugarcoating it: Levis was difficult to watch at times in 2022. His stats against Power Five opponents can be seen below:
PFF Passing Grade 61.2
Yards per Game 179.4
Comp % 62.2%
TDs 10
INTs 7
Big-Time Throws 5
Turnover-Worthy Plays 7
There’s nary a data point or advanced stat in the PFF database that can make the above palatable. There are only excuses for why it was the case. He was under pressure on 37.8% of his dropbacks (FBS average: 31.4% | NFL average: 33.6%). He threw a tight-window pass on 46.4% of his attempts targeted 10-plus yards downfield (FBS average: 39.2% | NFL average: 39.7%). While that speaks to just how difficult Levis’ job description was for the Wildcats this past fall, it says nothing about how he’ll fare when his supporting cast improves.
Luckily, we got a glimpse of just that in 2021. When he had a receiver who could get open at an NFL level (Wan’Dale Robinson) and a coordinator who could coordinate at an NFL level (Liam Coen), Levis earned a 90.6 overall grade. His tape against the behemoth Georgia defense that season was as good as anyone not named Bryce Young looked against them all season long.
He finished with an 83.3 overall grade in that game and made a grand total of zero turnover-worthy plays. While it was itself tremendous tape for evaluators, if that was the guy we saw every week, I wouldn’t even be writing this article. Levis would already be a shoo-in to be the No. 1 overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft. And therein lies the most difficult of the three questions to answer in scouting. We’re all just trying to answer the question of how likely it is that a player reaches their maximum capabilities on a consistent basis. Because Levis has proven that his capabilities are sky-high, but he’s shown them so infrequently that a road to consistency seems arduous to attain.
When you have to be the last one standing in a 32-team league chock-full of physical freaks at the quarterback position, however, it’s the quarterbacks with the high-end maximum capabilities who can get you to a Lombardi Trophy. That’s why Will Levis is still very worthy of — and in my opinion, will be — a top-five draft pick come April 27.
And how about a Mock Draft from Dane Brugler of The Athletic:
The underclassman deadline has come and gone, so we now know the official pool of players available for the 2023 NFL Draft. We also have the official draft order for the first 23 selections. Picks 24 through 31 will come into focus throughout the playoffs (remember, the Dolphins forfeited their first-rounder, so there will be only 31 picks in Round 1 this year).
Normally, I hate projecting trades this early in the process, but the overwhelming odds say the Bears will trade out of the No. 1 spot. I’ve also added two more first-round trades as teams look to jump up for quarterbacks.
Mock 2.0:
Round 1
1. Indianapolis Colts (via Chicago): Bryce Young, QB, Alabama
Projected trade: No. 1 for Nos. 4, 35 and a 2024 first-round pick
This trade makes sense for both sides. The Colts have a clear need at quarterback, with an owner and general manager who are motivated to get it right. Colts GM Chris Ballard, who was previously a scout in Chicago, is very familiar with Bears GM Ryan Poles — the two worked together for four years in the Chiefs’ front office. This would mark the third time over the last 25 years that the Colts held the No. 1 pick. It worked out well the other two times: Peyton Manning and Andrew Luck.
Bryce Young is a complete outlier from a size perspective and would be somewhat off-type for Ballard, but Young’s instincts, vision and accuracy as a passer are the traits worth betting on at the position. It won’t be a driving reason behind a trade up, but sniping Young ahead of division foe Houston would be an added benefit.
2. Houston Texans: Will Levis, QB, Kentucky
Obviously, this selection will be heavily influenced by the Texans’ new hire at head coach. It wouldn’t be a surprise, however, if Houston’s key decision-makers wind up with Will Levis atop their draft board. The Kentucky passer is built for the NFL game and checks numerous boxes with his size, mobility, arm strength, intelligence and competitive toughness.
Levis didn’t have the senior season many expected, with a new play caller and a subpar supporting cast compared to the previous year. Some evaluators will say those are excuses; others see it more as an explanation. Regardless, the traits — both physical and mental — are impressive and will lead several NFL teams to believe he is QB1 in this class.
3. Arizona Cardinals: Will Anderson Jr., Edge, Alabama
Since Kyler Murray isn’t going anywhere, Arizona’s new general manager and head coach will be hoping that quarterbacks come off the board with the first two selections, which would give the Cardinals the opportunity to draft the top non-QB.
An outstanding pass rusher and run defender, Will Anderson Jr., has a bendy, flexible frame with explosiveness in his upper half to attack from different positions. His junior season (10 sacks, 17 tackles for loss, one interception) didn’t quite live up to his remarkable sophomore year (17.5 sacks, 31 tackles for loss), but he still ranked top five in the nation in quarterback pressures. J.J. Watt’s retirement means that the Cardinals are losing one of the best pass rushers in NFL history, but adding Anderson would give the franchise a new defensive cornerstone for the future.
4. Chicago Bears (via Indianapolis): Jalen Carter, DT, Georgia
For the next few months, Bears fans will be debating between Anderson and Jalen Carter. In this scenario, the decision is made for them. Carter is young, which is evident in several areas of his game, but it is also clear how uniquely talented he is with his combination of body control and power. His block destruction and disruption are special.
For Bears fans screaming that the return in this trade scenario (this pick, No. 35 and a future first) isn’t enough, there would be added value in trading back with the Colts, as opposed to the Raiders (No. 7 overall), Panthers (No. 9 overall) or another team. The opportunity to stay within striking distance of the two “elite” defensive prospects in this draft should give the Colts a hypothetical advantage if the Bears have multiple offers to consider.
5. Carolina Panthers (via Seattle): C.J. Stroud, QB, Ohio State
Projected trade: No. 5 for Nos. 9, 93 and a 2024 first-round pick
Two years ago, the Panthers decided to pass on an Ohio State quarterback (Justin Fields). In this draft, they might be trading up for a different Buckeye. Regardless of Carolina’s head coach hire, we know ownership will heavily influence what the team does with this top-10 pick, and it is fair to assume David Tepper is tired of the quarterback carousel of veteran washouts.
With his accuracy and ability to read the field, C.J. Stroud can carve up defenses if given time to operate from the pocket. Although it came in a playoff-semifinal loss to Georgia, Stroud had a career performance in his final college game (348 yards passing, four touchdowns). On that tape, Stroud showed an improved comfort level when he was required to create outside of structure, which will only help him throughout the draft process.
6. Detroit Lions (via L.A. Rams): Christian Gonzalez, CB, Oregon
After Anderson and Carter, there is a clear drop-off to the next tier of non-quarterback prospects in this class.
Christian Gonzalez flashed enough at Colorado to earn the No. 9 spot on my summer top-50 board, and he lived up to that hype in his one season at Oregon. With his speed/length athletic profile and the Lions’ need at cornerback, Gonzalez (the brother-in-law of former Lions’ backup quarterback David Blough) should be on Detroit’s short list for its first of two Round 1 picks.
7. Las Vegas Raiders: Paris Johnson Jr., OT, Ohio State
With Derek Carr on his way out the door, we know the Raiders will be doing their homework on this quarterback class. They might not be in a position to get their top-ranked guy, though.
The Raiders got better-than-expected play this season from right tackle Jermaine Eluemunor, but he is a free agent, and investing in the offensive line is never a bad way to go. Paris Johnson Jr. is a fluid big man with length and power and the gifts to recover when he misfires his punch.
8. Atlanta Falcons: Peter Skoronski, OT/G, Northwestern
Originally, I had the Falcons keeping Georgia left tackle Broderick Jones in his home state with this pick, but Peter Skoronski would give Atlanta a little more flexibility on the offensive line. While his lack of length is a legitimate concern, Skoronski has outstanding tape due to his feet, technique and processing. Scouts believe he has five-position versatility, which would allow the Falcons to move him around and get their five best blockers on the field.
9. Seattle Seahawks (via Carolina): Tyree Wilson, Edge, Texas Tech
If you watched the Seahawks wilt in the second half of their wild-card matchup against the 49ers, you know that their defense needs help. At 6-foot-6 and 270 pounds with almost 36-inch arms, Tyree Wilson is a big, powerful athlete who can be disruptive from various alignments along the defensive line.
10. Philadelphia Eagles (via New Orleans): Joey Porter Jr., CB, Penn State
With James Bradberry likely to get paid elsewhere this offseason, the Eagles will be looking to address the cornerback position. Joey Porter Jr., the son of a former Pro Bowler, is a long and physical (sometimes, too physical) athlete with the cover skills that might land him in the top 10.
11. Tennessee Titans: Broderick Jones, OT, Georgia
Depending on what the Titans do in free agency, this could be a very offensive line-focused draft. Nine years ago, the franchise used the No. 11 pick on a promising left tackle named Taylor Lewan, who became a Pro Bowler. With Lewan looming as a potential offseason cut, history could repeat itself here and land Jones in Tennessee.
12. Houston Texans (from Cleveland): Bryan Bresee, DT, Clemson
The Texans drafted their quarterback earlier and now they address the defensive line. After his Freshman All-America season in 2020, Bryan Bresee totaled just 27 tackles over the past two years as he battled injuries and personal tragedy. But, as long as the medicals check out, he is an explosive player worthy of a spot in the top half of Round 1.
13. New York Jets: Brian Branch, S, Alabama
One of the best defensive players in the draft, Brian Branch was the linchpin of Nick Saban’s defense in Tuscaloosa, and his versatility as a nickel or safety will translate well to the pro game. Although he doesn’t have ideal size, Branch is outstanding in coverage and a strong tackler.
14. New England Patriots: Myles Murphy, Edge, Clemson
Smooth, strong and long, Myles Murphy has a lot of the traits that would appeal to Bill Belichick. Given his expected testing numbers at the scouting combine, Murphy will create buzz throughout the process, even though his rush plan and setup are still in the development phase.
15. Detroit Lions (via Green Bay): Anthony Richardson, QB, Florida
Projected trade: No. 15 for Nos. 18 and 48
In last year’s first round, the Lions made a major trade with a division foe to move up for a high-upside offensive star (Jameson Williams). They could do it again this year and invest in their future at the quarterback position.
Thanks to his size, athleticism and arm, Anthony Richardson is a total freak show with a high ceiling, but he’s still figuring out how to be a consistent passer. Jared Goff’s presence would let Detroit develop Richardson at his own pace.
16. Washington Commanders: Cam Smith, CB, South Carolina
The Commanders’ cornerback play was frustratingly inconsistent this season, so there should be changes coming. Although he’s not quite on the same level as his former college teammate, Jaycee Horn, Cam Smith is stylistically similar with his length, light-footed movements and aggressive approach.
17. Pittsburgh Steelers: Devon Witherspoon, CB, Illinois
Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin is going to love Devon Witherspoon. No, Witherspoon doesn’t have ideal size (under 6-0 and 185 pounds), but the Pensacola, Fla., native plays with the fiery demeanor and physicality of a much bigger player. His mentality plus his controlled movements and coverage anticipation will make him an NFL starter from day one.
18. Green Bay Packers (via Detroit): Lukas Van Ness, DL, Iowa
This feels like a very Packers pick, right? Lukas Van Ness was not even a starter for the Hawkeyes and might not have the most impressive collegiate resume. With his explosive power and upside, though, the Iowa product has the toolsy profile that Green Bay covets on the defensive line.
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Drew Sanders, LB, Arkansas
With Lavonte David’s future in Tampa Bay uncertain, the Buccaneers might need to replace one of the best defensive players in franchise history. A former five-star recruit at Alabama, Drew Sanders is coming off a breakout season (103 tackles and 9.5 sacks) and boasts the athletic range and instincts that could make him the first linebacker drafted.
20. Seattle Seahawks: Jordan Addison, WR, USC
If the Seahawks invest in Geno Smith for the short term, surrounding him with more talent would be an understandable strategy. The first receiver drafted here, Jordan Addison has inconsistent play strength, but he is a twitchy athlete with the crafty routes and play speed to work all three levels of the field.
21. Los Angeles Chargers: Michael Mayer, TE, Notre Dame
The Chargers need to make changes this offseason, and it will be interesting to see what buttons they push. Something the organization should be trying to do every year is upgrade on offense around their talented quarterback, Justin Herbert. Michael Mayer is a physical blocker and will be one of the best contested-catch tight ends in the NFL the moment he is drafted.
22. Baltimore Ravens: Kelee Ringo, CB, Georgia
This pick is reminiscent of when the Ravens drafted Marlon Humphrey in the mid-first round in 2017. Like Humphrey, Kelee Ringo has above-average size, speed and the compete skills to immediately match up with NFL receivers. But his route anticipation and awareness are still immature, which is why not all NFL teams view him as a first-round lock.
23. Minnesota Vikings: Deonte Banks, CB, Maryland
Between now and the draft, I’m sure we will hear plenty of quarterback talk surrounding the Vikings. But they also need help on defense, obviously, including in the secondary. A cover-and-clobber corner, Deonte Banks has rangy speed and ball skills. Several NFL teams have second-round grades on the Maryland corner, but others believe he can crack the first round.
24. Jacksonville Jaguars: Darnell Washington, TE, Georgia
Back in the 2006 NFL Draft, the Jaguars drafted a big combo tight end late in the first round: Marcedes Lewis, who’d go on to be a Pro Bowler in Jacksonville. Darnell Washington is even bigger than Lewis and has better upside as both a pass catcher and blocker. His unique skill set will mean he’s valued differently by every offense, but it would be fun to see how he could blossom within the Jaguars’ offensive ecosystem.
25. New York Giants: Quentin Johnston, WR, TCU
The Giants have gotten better-than-expected play from wide receivers like Isaiah Hodgins this season, but the position remains an area of need. Quentin Johnston is an intriguing evaluation because he has outstanding physical traits, like size (6-4, 215), speed (4.4 40-yard dash) and springs in his legs. He also tracks the ball naturally, although he will have focus drops and his route running is a work in progress. Johnston has the talent to warrant top-20 consideration, but he isn’t a lock to go that high.
26. Dallas Cowboys: Siaki Ika, NT, Baylor
History tells us this won’t be the pick — the Cowboys haven’t drafted a defensive tackle in the top 50 since Russell Maryland at No. 1 in 1991. However, the Cowboys are committed to upgrading their defense and Ika would give them a boulder in the middle of the line. At 355 pounds, Ika is a hard guy to move at the point of attack, but he also has the short-area quickness to be disruptive.
27. Cincinnati Bengals: Luke Musgrave, TE, Oregon State
The third tight end off the board in this mock, Luke Musgrave would be much more well-known had he not missed most of his senior year with an injury. At 6-foot-6, 250 pounds with 4.5 speed, he is an impressive athlete for the position and has strength and body fluidity as both a blocker and receiver. Adding a weapon like this to the Bengals offense would create fireworks.
28. Denver Broncos (via San Francisco): O’Cyrus Torrence, OG, Florida
How many returning starters will the Broncos have on their offensive line next season? Changes are coming. O’Cyrus Torrence is a large, physical guard with vice grips for hands and the drive power to create movement in the run game. He could be a starter in Denver from day one.
29. Buffalo Bills: Antonio Johnson, S, Texas A&M
Whether you ask him to play free, strong or nickel safety, Antonio Johnson has the talent to fill any of those roles at a high level. He competes with a physical nature to defeat blocks and make plays near the line of scrimmage, but he also offers the range and balance to cover in space.
30. Kansas City Chiefs: Jaxon Smith-Njigba, WR, Ohio State
With the MVP of the league at quarterback, the Chiefs might not feel compelled to use first-round capital on a wide receiver. If the “right” pass catcher is there, though, it might change their thinking. Even though he isn’t the top-10 pick some seem to think, Jaxon Smith-Njigba already runs routes like a pro and has the ball skills that will translate well to the NFL game.
31. Philadelphia Eagles: Bijan Robinson, RB, Texas
The last time the Eagles drafted a running back in the first round, Ron Jaworski was Philadelphia’s starting quarterback. But Bijan Robinson is one of the best talents in this draft class and would be a bargain with the final pick of Round 1. The Texas running back has no business falling this far. There just aren’t too many clear landing spots within the top 30 picks.
Round 2
32. Pittsburgh Steelers (via Chicago): Trenton Simpson, LB, Clemson
Giving up Chase Claypool for an ultra-athletic linebacker like Trenton Simpson? I think the Steelers would be happy with that outcome.
33. Houston Texans: Josh Downs, WR, North Carolina
34. Arizona Cardinals: Clark Phillips III, CB, Utah
35. Chicago Bears (via Indianapolis): BJ Ojulari, Edge, LSU
36. Los Angeles Rams: Nolan Smith, Edge, Georgia
37. Seattle Seahawks (via Denver): Gervon Dexter Sr., DT, Florida
38. Las Vegas Raiders: Zach Harrison, Edge, Ohio State
39. Carolina Panthers: Jahmyr Gibbs, RB, Alabama
Carolina general manager Scott Fitterer said the Panthers will hunt “explosive-type” players in the draft and Gibbs is exactly that, both as a runner and receiver.
40. New Orleans Saints: Tucker Kraft, TE, South Dakota State
41. Tennessee Titans: Jalin Hyatt, WR, Tennessee
42. Cleveland Browns: Mazi Smith, DT, Michigan
Would Mazi Smith be the best defensive tackle on the Browns roster the moment he’s drafted? It’s no mystery that is a position of need for Cleveland.
43. New York Jets: Cody Mauch, OL, North Dakota State
44. Atlanta Falcons: Tyler Scott, WR, Cincinnati
45. Green Bay Packers: Dalton Kincaid, TE, Utah
46. New England Patriots: Rashee Rice, WR, SMU
47. Washington Commanders: Anton Harrison, OT, Oklahoma
48. Green Bay Packers (via Detroit): A.T. Perry, WR, Wake Forest
49. Pittsburgh Steelers: Matthew Bergeron, OT/G, Syracuse
50. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Kyu Blu Kelly, CB, Stanford
Tampa Bay drafted Brian Kelly at No. 45 in 1998, and he helped the franchise win a Super Bowl. The Bucs could try to repeat history 25 years later with Kelly’s son, Kyu Blu.
51. Miami Dolphins: Devon Achane, RB, Texas A&M
52. Seattle Seahawks: Emmanuel Forbes, CB, Mississippi State
53. Chicago Bears (via Baltimore): Cedric Tillman, WR, Tennessee
54. Los Angeles Chargers: Jaelyn Duncan, OT/G, Maryland
55. Detroit Lions (via Minnesota): Isaiah Foskey, Edge, Notre Dame
56. Jacksonville Jaguars: Keeanu Benton, DT, Wisconsin
57. New York Giants: Jack Campbell, LB, Iowa
58. Dallas Cowboys: DJ Turner, CB, Michigan
Neither of Dallas’ Day 2 cornerbacks from the 2021 draft (Kelvin Joseph, Nahshon Wright) have been dependable. It is time to reinvest in the position.
59. Cincinnati Bengals: Dawand Jones, OT, Ohio State
60. Carolina Panthers (via San Francisco): Keion White, DL, Georgia Tech
61. Buffalo Bills: Zay Flowers, WR, Boston College
62. Kansas City Chiefs: Mike Morris, Edge, Michigan
63. Philadelphia Eagles: Derick Hall, Edge, Auburn
With three picks in the first two rounds, Eagles GM Howie Roseman is going to draft at least one pass rusher, right? Here, Derick Hall goes from War Eagle to Philadelphia Eagle. |