WEAPONS RACE
Bill Barnwell of ESPN.com ranks the weapons each NFL QB has at his disposal – 32 (Texans) to 1 (Buccaneers) to 32. We go with the bottom 5 and top 5, editing out the discussion of those in the middle:
Every year, we get new reminders for just how important it is to surround your quarterback with the right talent. Just take the quarterbacks from the class of 2018. While Cleveland’s Baker Mayfield was thriving in 2020 behind a great offensive line and with the right coaching staff, Sam Darnold’s third and final season with the Jets was a waste of time. Baltimore’s Lamar Jackson spent most of a playoff loss to the Bills patiently waiting for any one of his receivers to get open, while Buffalo’s Josh Allen enjoyed having Stefon Diggs on his side of the field.
Of course, while Super Bowl LV came down to a dismal Chiefs offensive line, let’s consider who got there. Kansas City has surrounded Patrick Mahomes with some of the best weapons in football for each of his first three seasons as a starter. Tom Brady looked like a new man in Tampa Bay, where he went from playing with a tired group of receivers in New England to an embarrassment of riches in Florida. This stuff matters.
Let’s do something that doesn’t really matter but is still fun anyway: We’ll rank each of the league’s 32 teams by their skill-position talent without including the impact of the quarterback, offensive line or scheme. That’s a very important caveat! Imagine if you took each team’s running backs and receivers and dropped them into an average offense with an average coach and an average starting quarterback. Who would have the best offense in football?
Here are a few other things to keep in mind before we get started:
This is about only 2021 performance. We’re not considering a player’s contract status, cap hit or long-term prognosis. We want to field the best possible group of weapons for a 17-game season in 2021. Since we don’t know how rookies will turn out, we’re using draft status and history to inform their chances of making an impact.
Wide receivers are weighted more heavily than running backs or tight ends. The league values wide receivers by giving players at the top of that market much larger deals than their friends at running back and tight end. The top average annual salary for a running back is Christian McCaffrey’s, at $16 million per season. At tight end, George Kittle is tops at $15 million. Twelve different wideouts are on multiyear deals averaging more than $16 million per year. As a result, I’ve weighted wideout talent as more significant than similarly gifted players elsewhere, although there’s a bigger drop-off between the top tight ends and the players in the second and third tiers at that position.
32. Houston Texans
2020 rank: 27 | 2019 rank: 16
The Texans might rank 32nd in a lot of categories by the time the season is over. The move to swap DeAndre Hopkins for David Johnson and a second-round pick was a disaster on its face and doesn’t look much better a year later, with Johnson ranking 41st in success rate in his first season with the Texans. Former Houston coach/general manager Bill O’Brien’s swap of a second-rounder for Brandin Cooks looks much better, with the oft-traded wideout producing a 1,150-yard campaign in 2020, but the decision to sign Randall Cobb was even worse than it seemed at the time.
In many cases, the names are bigger than the games on what amounts to a great fantasy football team from 2016. New general manager Nick Caserio signed veterans such as Rex Burkhead, Donte Moncrief and Mark Ingram this offseason to fill out the roster this spring, with Phillip Lindsay as one of the few younger additions to the fold. This is a skill-position group of stopgaps for a franchise stuck in neutral.
31. Detroit Lions
2020 rank: 25 | 2019 rank: 18
The Lions are at least trying to generate future capital and generally go with younger players. They chose a 2022 third-round compensatory pick over possibly franchising Kenny Golladay, and while that pick might be more valuable to the organization in the long haul than a player who turns 28 in November, the Lions have left themselves with the worst wide receivers room in the league. Nominal top options Breshad Perriman and Tyrell Williams are both best served as the third or fourth member of a passing attack while running 10-15 go routes per game. Fourth-rounder Amon-Ra St. Brown would be depth-chart fodder in some organizations; here, he might have a chance to lead all wideouts in targets.
Things are better elsewhere in the lineup. Tight end T.J. Hockenson isn’t in the top tier at his position, but he finished as the TE5 in fantasy football last season and could amass a preposterous target share from Jared Goff this season. D’Andre Swift showed promise after the Lions finally stopped giving the ball to Adrian Peterson, but the new regime shows little faith in the 2020 35th overall pick, having already imported Jamaal Williams before bringing in Todd Gurley for a visit. Williams was effective for the Packers last season, but new coach Dan Campbell & Co. need to see what they have with Swift. Politely, I will suggest that doing so will not cost the Lions any chance of going to the postseason.
30. New York Jets
2020 rank: 29 | 2019 rank: 20
General manager Joe Douglas’ goal was to get 2021 No. 2 pick Zach Wilson more weapons than his predecessor, Sam Darnold. At wide receiver, the Jets have certainly succeeded. Corey Davis might never live up to being the No. 5 overall pick in the 2017 draft, but he racked up 984 yards in 14 games for a run-first Titans offense last season and should be the focal point of a similar play-action scheme for New York this season. Second-rounder Elijah Moore is getting as much hype as any rookie in the NFL this offseason, and veterans Keelan Cole and Jamison Crowder are solid options in the slot.
The problem is, well, everything else. Chris Herndon’s expected breakout season was DOA in 2020, and while I like the addition of former Bills tight end Tyler Kroft, the Jets aren’t thrilling at tight end. They’re totally anonymous at running back, where fourth-rounder Michael Carter might win the job by default ahead of Tevin Coleman and La’Mical Perine. It’s probably the right idea to save at tailback for a team running the Shanahan/Kubiak offense, but it’s hard to get enthused about the backs on new coach Robert Saleh’s depth chart.
29. Philadelphia Eagles
2020 rank: 10 | 2019 rank: 4
The biggest drop-off on this year’s list belongs to the Eagles, who will be relying on back-to-back first-rounders at wide receiver to kick-start their offense. I’m wildly excited to watch DeVonta Smith after the 2020 Heisman Trophy winner looked like the best player on the field for most of the College Football Playoff, but if Smith isn’t an immediate superstar, this could threaten Detroit’s receiving corps. It’s way too early to give up on 2020 first-rounder Jalen Reagor, but the TCU product was anonymous as a rookie. Behind him is disappointing second-rounder J.J. Arcega-Whiteside, Travis Fulgham and Greg Ward, who the Eagles seemingly plan on moving on from every year, only for Ward to be their No. 1 wideout by mid-November. That can’t happen again.
While there are big names elsewhere for the Eagles, we haven’t seen steady production out of either running back Miles Sanders or tight end Dallas Goedert. Sanders was efficient as a runner last season, but he struggled with fumbles and had no impact as a receiver. A slight uptick in Goedert’s numbers was offset by the fact that he missed the better part of five games with injuries before a Week 17 white flag inactive. Zach Ertz is nominally included here, but he’s unlikely to be on Philadelphia’s Week 1 roster. There are plenty of possibilities here if the young draftees take a step forward, but seeing will be believing in Philly.
28. Indianapolis Colts
2020 rank: 26 | 2019 rank: 12
New Colts quarterback Carson Wentz will leave behind those Eagles in 2021, but while he’s blessed with an impressive offensive line in Indianapolis, this is another team counting on its young players to develop. The most prominent veteran at the skill-position spots here is T.Y. Hilton, who didn’t bounce back in 2020 after injuries impacted his 2019 season. 2019 second-round pick Parris Campbell has basically lost his first two seasons to injuries, with a knee issue costing him the final 14 games of 2020. The hope is that Michael Pittman Jr. breaks through as a No. 1 receiver, but even if he does, will there be much around the 2020 second-rounder? Tight end Jack Doyle has been around seemingly since the Peyton Manning era, but is Mo Alie-Cox going to have a Logan Thomas-style breakout in 2021?
Seven picks after the Colts drafted Pittman, they used the 41st selection on another key contributor in running back Jonathan Taylor. The Wisconsin product broke out over the final six games of 2020, finishing second among all backs with 741 rushing yards over that time frame. While 253 of those yards came in a Week 17 romp over a Jags team that might as well have been on the beach already, the one-two punch of Taylor and Nyheim Hines works. The story at receiver, at least for now, is more about hope than anything else.
27. New England Patriots
2020 rank: 21 | 2019 rank: 9
Rookie quarterback Mac Jones’ weapons at Alabama would have come in ahead of the players he’ll line up alongside with the Patriots in 2021.
26. Chicago Bears
2020 rank: 28 | 2019 rank: 17
At least for one season, Allen Robinson’s career of playing with overmatched, desperate quarterbacks could come to an end. Justin Fields is, at the very least, a better prospect than any of the passers Robinson has worked with regularly during his NFL career, and it should hopefully unlock a new level from the franchise-tagged receiver.
25. Jacksonville Jaguars
2020 rank: 31 | 2019 Rank: 32
The big upgrade the Jags made this offseason isn’t included as part of this analysis, but No. 1 overall pick Trevor Lawrence won’t lack for weapons in his rookie year. There might not be a No. 1 wideout in the mix, but D.J. Chark looked like he was on his way to becoming that guy in 2019, and Laviska Shenault should benefit from playing for a better offensive staff in 2021. Marvin Jones should be a consistent No. 3 target, although it took three 110-plus-yard games last December to get the veteran’s 2020 numbers up to respectable. There’s absolutely nothing in the cupboard at tight end, so expect plenty of three-wide sets from new offensive coordinator Darrell Bevell and coach Urban Meyer.
Undrafted free agent James Robinson came out of nowhere and was a totally viable starting running back, which is why the decision to draft Travis Etienne in Round 1 in April felt frustrating. Leaving the draft capital aside, though, a Robinson-Etienne one-two punch could be impressive.
24. Washington Football Team
2020 rank: 32 | 2019 rank: 28
There were signs of life around Terry McLaurin last season! At running back, Antonio Gibson was a Week 1 starter and proved to be an effective player despite his lack of experience, averaging 4.7 yards per carry while finishing sixth in the league in DVOA. The other surprising seasons weren’t quite as impressive; J.D. McKissic’s 80-catch effort was mostly a product of Alex Smith tossing the former Seahawks tailback checkdowns, while Logan Thomas ranked 35th among tight ends in yards per target. They were both more effective in fantasy football than the real thing.
23. Atlanta Falcons
2020 rank: 12 | 2019 Rank: 10
As it turns out, trading Julio Jones has deleterious effects on your spot in these weapons rankings. Atlanta still has one star at wide receiver in Calvin Ridley, but if Ridley’s foot issues linger into the season, the depth chart at wideout would be absolutely horrific.
22. Las Vegas Raiders
2020 rank: 24 | 2019 rank: 23
The Raiders keep hanging around this spot while they try to find an identity at wide receiver. Of course, their No. 1 weapon is a true superstar in tight end Darren Waller, who followed a 1,145-yard campaign in 2019 with a 1,196-yard season
21. Miami Dolphins
2020 rank: 30 | 2019 rank: 30
Last year in this space, we finished the Dolphins blurb by suggesting that they would add at least one and possibly two starting wide receivers after the 2020 season. Enter Will Fuller and Jaylen Waddle.
20. Los Angeles Chargers
2020 rank: 16 | 2019 rank: 11
As impressive as Justin Herbert’s rookie season was, it’s hard to point to one of his weapons as having a similarly exciting campaign.
19. New Orleans Saints
2020 rank: 6 | 2019 rank: 7
The Saints’ situation at the skill-position spots is a microcosm for the moves they had to make to clear out nearly $100 million in cap space this offseason. Are their stars still here? Yes. Sean Payton’s two best weapons are Alvin Kamara and Michael Thomas, and they’re back for another go-round. Are the pieces around them as good as they were over the past couple of years? Absolutely not.
18. Arizona Cardinals
2020 rank: 9 | 2019 rank: 27
For now, there’s DeAndre Hopkins, and then there’s everyone else.
17. Denver Broncos
2020 rank: 14 | 2019 rank: 31
What looked like a cast of budding stars heading into 2020 didn’t pan out. Courtland Sutton tore an ACL in the opener, and while Tim Patrick had a quietly solid season in Sutton’s absence, it took a Week 17 performance against a lowly Raiders defense to get Jerry Jeudy’s rookie numbers looking decent.
16. New York Giants
2020 rank: 7 | 2019 rank: 8
For as many promising pieces as the Giants sport, the offense doesn’t add up to the sum of its parts. As exciting as Saquon Barkley might look on a highlight reel, the former Penn State star has now missed most of one season with a torn ACL and hobbled through a second with a high ankle sprain. Kenny Golladay, the team’s new addition at wideout, missed most of 2020 with hip and hamstring injuries. Darius Slayton repeated his 2019 numbers, but he did so on 176 more snaps. Tight end Evan Engram continues to struggle with drops and averaged just 6.0 yards per target last season. First-round pick Kadarius Toney could be a valuable weapon in the slot, but his presence conflicts with Sterling Shepard’s best spot, just as was the case with Golden Tate two years ago.
15. Pittsburgh Steelers
2020 rank: 13 | 2019 rank: 15
The Steelers have become a wideout factory in recent years, so perhaps we shouldn’t have been surprised when third-round pick Chase Claypool immediately established himself as an impact contributor….So, why did they fall back two spots from where they were a year ago? I’m not as optimistic about Smith-Schuster, who had one of the most spectacular sophomore seasons in league history and then followed it with an injury-hit 2019.
14. Baltimore Ravens
2020 rank: 20 | 2019 rank: 26
After watching Lamar Jackson fruitlessly wait for receivers to come open in the AFC Championship Game, the Ravens acted and added Sammy Watkins and first-round pick Rashod Bateman to their receiving corps.
13. Cincinnati Bengals
2020 rank: 23 | 2019 rank: 13
I’m always a little skeptical about the impact of rookies when I make these rankings, but it’s not hard to be more optimistic about Ja’Marr Chase than the vast majority of other first-year wideouts. The scary thing for the AFC North is that Chase might not even be the team’s top target as a rookie, given that Tee Higgins was wildly impressive while Joe Burrow was on the field and Tyler Boyd has settled in as one of the league’s top slot receivers.
12. San Francisco 49ers
2020 rank: 18 | 2019 rank: 24
Oh, if the 49ers could keep everyone healthy on the field at the same time!
11. Green Bay Packers
2020 rank: 19 | 2019 rank: 19
If Aaron Rodgers wasn’t going to get any new weapons last year, the future Hall of Famer was just going to make some for himself. Out of relative anonymity came Robert Tonyan, who went from catching 14 career passes between 2018 and 2019 to finishing as the TE3 in 2020. It’ll be near-impossible for Tonyan to keep up his touchdown rate (21.2%) or catch rate (88.1%) in 2021, but he gave the Packers a second option in the red zone behind Davante Adams.
As for Adams? He was virtually uncoverable for most of the season; I don’t think I’ve ever seen the primary option in an offense wide open more frequently in tight situations than Adams was last season, when he racked up 1,374 yards and 18 touchdowns across 13.5 games.
10. Los Angeles Rams (before Cam Akers injury)
2020 rank: 11 | 2019 rank: 1
The offense might not be quite as glamorous or devastating as the peak with Todd Gurley and Brandin Cooks, but Robert Woods and Cooper Kupp keep plugging along as one of the best receiving duos in football…While Matthew Stafford might transform the offense, Cam Akers is the one whose production seems most up in the air. The Rams took their sweet time in getting to Akers as their featured running back; he got 14 carries in the opener and then didn’t top 10 carries in a game again until Week 13, at which point they gave him 132 attempts over his final six games. In the divisional-round loss to the Packers, Akers took 96% of the snaps on offense, the sort of workload the Rams gave to Gurley at his most dominant. If Stafford elevates the offense and Akers gets that sort of snap share, he could be one of the most productive backs in the league.
9. Buffalo Bills
2020 rank: 8 | 2019 Rank: 25
So much for the inevitable clash between Josh Allen and Stefon Diggs, huh? Allen found an immediate rapport with his star wideout, who went on to lead the NFL in both receptions (127) and receiving yards (1,535). Diggs excelled in his debut season with the Bills, who seemed to find valuable receiver contributors up and down their roster. Cole Beasley had his most productive season out of the slot and Gabriel Davis emerged as an immediate contributor, but this even goes down to Isaiah McKenzie, who scored five touchdowns across 30 catches.
How, then, are the Bills one spot below where they were a year ago? The running back and tight end spots are more about scheme and rotation than standout talent.
8. Seattle Seahawks
2020 rank: 15 | 2019 rank: 29
Depending on how you view running back Chris Carson, it’s either a big two or a big three for the Seahawks. Tyler Lockett and DK Metcalf were devastating in the first half of last season before the Seattle passing attack fell off during the final two months; the two starting wideouts accounted for nearly 47% of Russell Wilson’s pass attempts, as no other player on the roster was targeted more than 50 times.
7. Carolina Panthers
2020 rank: 5 | 2019 rank: 22
The Panthers rued the absence of their biggest star last season, as running back Christian McCaffrey reminded us to be cautious about using even a spotless health record to predict future availability. After playing nearly every snap in 2019, CMC missed 13 games with ankle, shoulder and quad injuries…If McCaffrey comes back strong, few teams can boast a big three quite as impressive as that of McCaffrey and wideouts Robby Anderson and DJ Moore.
6. Kansas City Chiefs
2020 rank: 1 | 2019 rank: 2
This is the lowest arsenal ranking for the Chiefs in the Patrick Mahomes era, in which his weapons have previously come in first, second and first again. The drop-off comes after Travis Kelce produced arguably the greatest season by a tight end in league history and Tyreek Hill chipped in with 1,276 receiving yards and 17 touchdowns. Nobody — not the Seahawks, not the Vikings, not anybody — had a better one-two punch of receiving weapons than the Chiefs did a year ago, and they’re both back for 2021.
Everything else doesn’t look quite as good. The earlier versions of these teams had Kareem Hunt, and while Clyde Edwards-Helaire was expected to be instantly impactful as Kansas City’s primary running back, the LSU product was mostly anonymous as a rookie.
5. Minnesota Vikings
2020 rank: 17 | 2019 rank: 5
It’s hard to think of a trade that looks more like a win-win for both sides after one season than the swap that sent Stefon Diggs to the Bills and allowed the Vikings to draft Justin Jefferson. All Jefferson did was produce one of the most impressive seasons by a rookie receiver in league history, as he led all receivers in yards (1,330) and yards per target (11.0) after entering the starting lineup in Week 3. Adam Thielen’s volume suffered, with the veteran losing a little over two targets per game from his 2018 peak, but he still scored a ho-hum 14 touchdowns.
At this point, everybody’s on the same page with Dalvin Cook: When the Vikings’ star running back is healthy, he’s right alongside Derrick Henry as the most fearsome back in all of football. Counting on him to be healthy can be dangerous. He missed two games in 2019 and had to leave three more with a shoulder injury. Last season, he sat out in Week 17 and missed a game and a half with a groin issue. Cook does more in 13 or 14 games than most backs do in a full season, but if we ever get to see the 2017 second-rounder piece together a full 17-game campaign, he’d be a threat to hit 2,000 yards.
4. Cleveland Browns
2020 rank: 2 | 2019 rank: 3
While Nick Chubb missed time last season, the biggest obstacle standing in the way of his path toward a rushing title isn’t injuries; it’s the presence of a second standout back in Kareem Hunt. It’s difficult to think of a team that had a top two at running back quite as impressive as Cleveland’s duo, and while backs aren’t as valuable as wide receivers in the modern league, the Browns get plenty of production out of Chubb and Hunt. They’re also deep at tight end, although Austin Hooper’s numbers fell back to earth without the benefit of the garbage time he enjoyed in Atlanta.
At wide receiver, though, the Browns might not be quite as impressive as the names suggest. Jarvis Landry finished with career lows in receptions (72) and receiving yards (840) coming off hip surgery. More disconcertingly, Odell Beckham Jr. was off to a slow start even before tearing an ACL in October. He’s now four years removed from being a superstar wideout, with his numbers dropping across the board after dealing with an ankle injury in 2017. OBJ is still only 28, but it would be a surprise if he again looked like the guy who tore up the league with the Giants from 2014 to ’16. If that Beckham shows up in 2021, the Browns would have the league’s best group of weapons on offense.
3. Tennessee Titans
2020 rank: 22 | 2019 rank: 21
Since the start of 2019, Derrick Henry has 3,567 rushing yards. Dalvin Cook, who ranks second in the league over that time frame, is 875 rushing yards behind. Henry’s role in the passing game is limited to catching the occasional screen, but even without that work, he’s 315 yards from scrimmage ahead of the other backs. He also leads the league with 35 touchdowns over that spell, and that’s without considering his postseason work. I’m scared about his workload, but he had 386 carries between the regular season and the playoffs in 2019 and didn’t look any worse for wear in 2020.
Of course, the Titans rose further up the charts after trading for Julio Jones, who will form a potentially devastating top-two receiver duo alongside A.J. Brown. They both have injury concerns — Jones was out for half of 2020 and Brown is coming off double knee surgery — but there were 11 receivers in the NFL who averaged more than 10 yards per target on 50 targets or more last season, and two of them now play in Tennessee. The Chiefs will be more explosive because they have Mahomes, but the Titans are about as close as it gets when it comes to the possibility of big plays given their talent at running back and receiver.
2. Dallas Cowboys
2020 rank: 3 | 2019 rank: 6
Just about everything else besides the weaponry went wrong for the Cowboys last season. Their defense couldn’t stop anybody. Quarterback Dak Prescott and their best offensive linemen were injured. Everybody’s numbers were down after Prescott was replaced by Andy Dalton and the team used backup tackles for virtually the entire season, but rookie wideout CeeDee Lamb looked like a star. We know what Amari Cooper and Michael Gallup can do with a healthy Prescott, and while tight end Blake Jarwin missed most of the year with a torn ACL, Dalton Schultz stepped in and racked up 615 yards with four touchdowns. That’s more receiving yards than Dallas Goedert has produced in any of his three NFL seasons.
The one weapon whose stock is down after 2020 might be Ezekiel Elliott. For all the talk about how Elliott was the guy who made Prescott and the rest of the offense tick, the running back looked entirely ordinary without his star quarterback. Elliott posted career lows in most categories and finished with a below-average DVOA, in part because he fumbled six times on 296 touches. His numbers should bounce back some with Prescott & Co. returning to the fold, but the arguments that he was a scheme- or line-transcendent back are firmly in the past. This is a passing team now.
1. Tampa Bay Buccaneers
2020 rank: 4 | 2019 rank: 14
Nobody in the league combines Tampa’s combination of top-level talent and supreme depth. Bruce Arians’ team has a true No. 1 receiver in Mike Evans. The guys behind him are massively overqualified for their roles; it’s an embarrassment of riches to have Chris Godwin as a second wideout and even a limited version of Antonio Brown as the No. 3. Scotty Miller would be a burgeoning starter for some teams; here, he’s a No. 4 who averages 9.5 yards per target.
The Bucs might not be quite as impressive at the other spots, but their starters at running back (Leonard Fournette) and tight end (Rob Gronkowski) were legitimate difference-makers during the postseason. They’re also blessed with deep depth charts at both spots, given that Fournette will be spelled by Ronald Jones and Gio Bernard, while Gronkowski will split time with Cameron Brate and the returning O.J. Howard. You could make a case for the Cowboys at No. 1 if you think Elliott is still a superstar back, and the Titans have a more impressive top three, but I think the Bucs are as good as it gets for skill-position talent.
|