TOP OF THE DRAFT
Mel Kiper and Todd McShay of ESPN.com discuss the top 10 picks for 2021:
As the 2021 NFL draft draws closer — we’re 142 days away from the start of Round 1 on April 29 — it’s officially mock draft season.
The winless Jets remain the favorite to land the No. 1 pick, and all signs are point toward them drafting a new quarterback. But what happens next? How do the Bengals help Joe Burrow? What do the Cowboys do with a potential top-five pick? Will the Eagles go back to the wide receiver well? Is it time for the Panthers to think offense? And could the Lions really draft a quarterback?
As we look ahead to April, NFL draft analysts Mel Kiper Jr. and Todd McShay answer those questions with their first mini mock draft, debating potential picks for teams primed to draft in the top 10 before arriving at a consensus pick in each slot. They begin with the Jets.
1. New York Jets (0-12)
The consensus pick: Trevor Lawrence, QB, Clemson
Kiper: This has to be Trevor Lawrence, right, Todd? I know the Jets have Sam Darnold, but can they really pass up Lawrence? He is the clear No. 1 quarterback in this class, a generational talent.
McShay: Well, let’s take a step back. It really comes down to whether the Jets believe Darnold is still their guy. Can he take them to a Super Bowl with the right supporting cast? Are they confident in where he is mentally? If they still have faith in him as their quarterback of the future, they could trade back and build their roster around him. Lawrence is extremely talented, but Darnold is still only 23 years old. This is not an easy call.
Kiper: It’s important to note that general manager Joe Douglas and coach Adam Gase — who’s on the hot seat — don’t have ties to Darnold. They didn’t draft him. They can reboot the franchise with a new quarterback. And I’d do that for Lawrence. Would you?
McShay: Lawrence is the best quarterback prospect I’ve seen in years — he has my highest QB grade since Andrew Luck in 2012 — and the top prospect in this class by a good margin. So, yes, if the Jets really don’t think Darnold is their guy, they have to take Lawrence. What do you think they could get in a Darnold trade, Mel?
Kiper: The obvious comparison is to what Arizona got in the Josh Rosen trade during the draft in 2019 — a second- and fifth-round pick. That came after the Cardinals had already drafted Kyler Murray, so they didn’t have much leverage with the Dolphins. The Jets won’t have much leverage, either, if they get the No. 1 pick. That would be a fair return. I do think the offseason market will help them. Teams with veteran quarterbacks — New Orleans, Pittsburgh, Tampa Bay and San Francisco come to mind — could make sense as trade partners.
McShay: And if the Jets win a game and fall to the No. 2 pick, I’d keep Darnold, trade back for more picks and help him rather than draft Justin Fields (Ohio State). They have four first-round picks over the next two years to fill the holes around him, and a trade down would only add to that stockpile.
Kiper: Interesting. I’d take Fields over Darnold, but I think I’d rather have a 23-year-old Darnold right now than Trey Lance (North Dakota State) or Zach Wilson (BYU) in this class. I believe in his talent. But I also believe that Lawrence is the better prospect, and I don’t see him staying in school for another year. He’s the No. 1 pick.
2. Jacksonville Jaguars (1-11)
The consensus pick: Justin Fields, QB, Ohio State
McShay: The Jaguars would be in a great spot at No. 2. They’ll have a new general manager and possibly a new coach. What are you thinking here, Mel?
Kiper: Look at Jacksonville’s recent history of top-five picks. Luke Joeckel, Blake Bortles, Dante Fowler Jr., Jalen Ramsey, Leonard Fournette — none of those guys are still on the roster. The Jaguars have a lot of needs, but the biggest hole is at quarterback. It’s not going to be Gardner Minshew. It’s not Jake Luton or Mike Glennon. They really have to get their guy. It has to be Fields if they get this pick.
McShay: Yeah, I would say that’s the play. But I’ll also admit that Fields’ game against Indiana scared me a little bit. He had as many touchdowns as incompletions entering that game (11), but then he threw three interceptions, took five sacks and completed just 60% of his passes against the Hoosiers. It just makes you wonder. That said, in this spot and with Lawrence off the board, Fields is the guy. He’s my No. 2 prospect overall and fills a massive need.
Kiper: You’re totally right; he had a poor game. Scouts will study that one hard. Were the interceptions just bad throws or a symptom of bigger issues? What I liked to see there is what he can bring with his feet — he rushed for 78 yards and a score. He’s a really good athlete. He can affect games in multiple ways. Ultimately, while he hasn’t closed the gulf with Lawrence, he has created separation as the No. 2 quarterback in this class. Do you agree?
McShay: Yes. It’s really an interesting QB class, and I think we could see five go in first round when it’s all said and done. After Lawrence and Fields, Lance, Wilson and Mac Jones (Alabama) have a good chance to be Day 1 selections. Kyle Trask (Florida) could even slide in there. But Fields is the clear No. 2 guy, thanks to his downfield accuracy and ability to throw off-schedule. Jacksonville can build around him.
3. Cincinnati Bengals (2-9-1)
The consensus pick: Penei Sewell, OT, Oregon
Kiper: This might be the easiest pick of the top 10 — unless Cincinnati gets wowed by a trade offer from a team looking to move up.
McShay: Offensive tackle Penei Sewell (Oregon) is a no-brainer. It was frustrating to watch the Bengals’ pass protection in front of Joe Burrow this year before the rookie No. 1 overall pick went down with a knee injury. When you invest a top pick in a franchise QB, you have to protect him. Cincinnati hasn’t — yet. Burrow took 32 sacks in 10 games, the third most in the NFL at the time. Sewell opted out of the 2020 season, but we’ve seen what he can do, and he’d be a major boost to an offensive line in need of talent.
Kiper: We don’t need to spend too long debating this one, though cornerback could be an option if the Bengals fall in love with Patrick Surtain II (Alabama) or Caleb Farley (Virginia Tech) or Shaun Wade (Ohio State). What I wrote last week about Sewell potentially being their new Anthony Munoz still stands. This is all about helping your young quarterback.
4. Los Angeles Chargers (3-9)
The consensus pick: Ja’Marr Chase, WR, LSU
McShay: Are we finally going to disagree on a pick? Personally, I think the Chargers could use a linebacker, even after drafting Kenneth Murray in Round 1 in April. What do you think of Micah Parsons out of Penn State here? He’s an impact player.
Kiper: I like Parsons a lot — he’s a tackling machine — but I question the fit with Murray. Are they really going to take another off-ball linebacker this early? Parsons has more upside as a pass-rusher than Murray, but general manager Tom Telesco could look to help Justin Herbert instead. I think this is a spot to watch for one of the elite pass-catchers — DeVonta Smith (Alabama), Ja’Marr Chase (LSU) or Kyle Pitts (Florida).
McShay: OK, I can see that. Los Angeles needs difference-makers on both sides of the ball, and if they go with the offensive side, there are plenty of talented receivers available here. I have Chase slightly ahead of Smith, and he’d fit in nicely alongside Keenan Allen and Mike Williams in the passing game. Another opt-out this season, Chase is explosive off the line and tracks the ball so well. How would you rank the wide receivers at the top, Mel?
Kiper: It’s really close with Smith and Chase. They’re essentially 1A and 1B. I can see why you like Chase a little bit more, but Smith is just so productive. All he does is score touchdowns — he has 15 this season. Could you imagine Smith or Chase on the field with Allen and Williams in 2021? The Chargers are in a fantastic spot to get their quarterback some help.
McShay: A lot of good options here, but I’d go with Chase.
Kiper: I can live with that. Allen, Williams and Chase would instantly become one of the NFL’s best receiving trios, though Williams will be a free agent in 2022. This is definitely a spot to watch for a potential trade up as well.
5. Dallas Cowboys (3-9)
The consensus pick: Micah Parsons, LB, Penn State
Kiper: OK, so who’s still left on the board? I want to find fits for Parsons, Smith, Pitts and Surtain soon. Are you thinking defense for Dallas? Is quarterback an option?
McShay: The Cowboys need to figure out the Dak Prescott contract situation. He’s a free agent after the season. The good news is they will know whether they need to draft a signal-caller by the time the draft rolls around. If they don’t re-sign Prescott, I think Wilson could make some sense here. I really like his game, and he’s going to rise over the next few months. But if they’re going to give Prescott a long-term deal, the defense can’t be ignored with this pick.
Kiper: I don’t see the Cowboys going with a quarterback. They have made it clear multiple times that Prescott is their guy. I’m inclined to believe them. And really, with Lawrence and Fields off the board, I don’t have top-five grades on Wilson or Lance. Let’s go with the other side of the ball here.
McShay: Defensive back has been a need for years in Dallas. Could Surtain be the answer? He’s not having the best year at Alabama, but he’s the top corner in the draft and can take away opposing No. 1 receivers. That’s something the Cowboys haven’t had. But there’s also just a ton of weak spots on this defense, so someone like Parsons could fit too.
Kiper: Surtain should be an option, but the Cowboys got a steal in 2020 second-rounder Trevon Diggs, who was having a good year before he broke his foot last month. Would they really go corner again? That’s why I’d lean toward Parsons. Yes, Dallas has used valuable picks on linebackers Jaylon Smith and Leighton Vander Esch, but Parsons is a better player right now. Vander Esch has had problems staying on the field, and Smith hasn’t lived up to his big contract. The Cowboys could move on from him as soon as this offseason.
McShay: Another opt-out, Parsons does a little bit of everything, and the Cowboys could use a little bit of everything. He can drop in coverage and stay with tight ends. He can be disruptive against the run and wrap up running backs turning the corner. And he can close on the quarterback when turned loose on a blitz.
Kiper: You know, really, the Cowboys got unlucky that there isn’t a premier edge rusher in this class. That’s what they need. But I don’t see a top-five or even top-10 pass-rusher in the 2021 group. Gregory Rousseau (Miami FL) and Kwity Paye (Michigan) are at the top of this class, but they’re not elite guys. I just don’t see Parsons getting past No. 5.
6. Atlanta Falcons (4-8)
The consensus pick: Patrick Surtain II, CB, Alabama
McShay: Atlanta is another team that will have a new general manager and coaching staff. And another team that has an underwhelming defense. Where do you see the Falcons’ needs, Mel?
Kiper: Cornerback, for sure. Edge rusher; free-agent signing Dante Fowler Jr. hasn’t worked out. Linebacker. Maybe tight end. But this is a team that gives up 6.2 yards per play — second worst in the league behind Jacksonville — so we have to go best defender left on the board. The two names that stuck out to me: Surtain and linebacker Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah (Notre Dame).
McShay: Oh, you’re finally coming around on Owusu-Koramoah? I love this dude’s tape. He’s so fast and instinctive. But I’ll be the first to admit this is high for him, and the sixth spot seems like an opportunity to move back, get some more picks and potentially still land Owusu-Koramoah.
Kiper: Every fan base loves to trade down, but it’s harder than it is on paper. General managers have to find teams that want to move up. I do think we could see teams try to get into the top 10 for Pitts or one of the wide receivers. They are special talents. But since we’re not doing trades here, are you thinking Surtain like I am, Todd?
McShay: Yeah, if it’s not a trade down, it has to be Surtain, even after drafting A.J. Terrell in Round 1 in April. Surtain brings shutdown corner upside to a defense searching for impact players, and he’s the best prospect available on that side of the ball. Lock it in and feel good about it.
7. Philadelphia Eagles (3-8-1)
The consensus pick: DeVonta Smith, WR, Alabama
Kiper: The Eagles have been one of the most disappointing teams in the league. We could go a bunch of different ways here, Todd. My first thought was offensive line, but I don’t have a top-10 grade on another lineman. Do you?
McShay: Not unless Philly is willing to make a big reach. Samuel Cosmi (Texas) and Rashawn Slater (Northwestern) are the next two on my board, but neither should be in consideration at No. 7. The Eagles have taken 53 sacks, the most in the league and nine more than the next-highest team. That’s ugly, but the value just isn’t here to make a fix.
Kiper: That’s fair, though I like Cosmi and Christian Darrisaw (Virginia Tech) as top-20 picks. If Surtain was still on the board, he’d be the pick as the corner opposite Darius Slay. This is a little high for my No. 2 corner Farley, who’s more like a mid-first-rounder. This is high for the edge rushers as well. What do you think about a wideout here, Todd? My guy DeVonta Smith is still on the board.
McShay: If Smith and Jaylen Waddle go in the first round next April, that’s four first-round Alabama wide receivers in two years. And of the bunch, Smith is probably the most consistent. He just pops off the line of scrimmage and accelerates. I know the Eagles took Jalen Reagor in the first round in April, but wideout is still a need. J.J. Arcega Whiteside — a second-rounder in 2019 — has 12 catches in two seasons, Alshon Jeffery is going to be 31 years old next season and Travis Fulgham has been up and down all year.
Kiper: The last time a team took a receiver in the first round in back-to-back years was 2005, when the Falcons, Lions and Jaguars all did it. That’s the move here. I’m not sure Reagor is a No. 1 wideout — he was No. 41 on my final 2020 Big Board — but he’d be a solid No. 2. Smith absolutely is a No. 1. He’s going to help Carson Wentz or Jalen Hurts or whomever is under center. He can be a superstar.
8. Carolina Panthers (4-8)
The consensus pick: Kyle Pitts, TE, Florida
McShay: In April, Carolina was the first NFL team in the modern era to use all of its draft picks on defensive players. The Panthers added seven, starting with tackle Derrick Brown. So we have to be thinking offense here, right?
Kiper: I think so. To me, this pick is pretty clear. There’s one more guy left on my board with an elite grade, and it’s at a position of need for the Panthers. Let’s get them an elite tight end in Pitts. What do you think, Todd?
McShay: He’s the perfect pick for Carolina. I don’t think it’s far-fetched to say he is the most difficult guy to cover in college football this season because of his size, separation ability and hands. The offensive line could use help, but I still think Cosmi is a bit overrated. Minnesota wide receiver Rashod Bateman is in play — he’s a lot like JuJu Smith-Schuster — as is Alabama’s Waddle. But Pitts is special.
Kiper: You like Bateman a little more than me — he’s my sixth-ranked receiver. Carolina, though, has 20 total catches from tight ends this season, led by Ian Thomas’ 13. Greg Olsen is long gone. Pitts would be a great pick to give Teddy Bridgewater a versatile weapon and nightmare for opposing defenses to cover.
McShay: Only 10 tight ends have ever been drafted in the top eight picks, but between his talent and Carolina’s need for playmaking pass-catchers, Pitts should be No. 11.
9. Detroit Lions (5-7)
The consensus pick: Zach Wilson, QB, BYU
Kiper: This is an interesting spot, and the Lions will have a new coach and general manager in 2021. It’s impossible to know for sure what they’re going to do. But my mind keeps going back to quarterback. Matthew Stafford is in his 12th season in Detroit. Lance and Wilson are still available. This franchise could go for a full reboot.
McShay: Zach Wilson makes a lot of sense. He’s the most underrated quarterback in the entire class, and I think he will continue to rise as we get closer to April. Stafford has been playing well, but he turns 33 in the offseason, and this is an opportunity for the Lions to get their next QB.
Kiper: I have Lance ranked higher right now, but it’s close and it’s a long time until draft day. I could see Wilson jumping him. Stafford, meanwhile, is signed through 2022, but there’s a scenario in which the Lions move on and either trade or release him this offseason. That would give the rookie quarterback a fresh start under a new regime. Todd, if they decided to stick with Stafford, what are the positions they should target here?
McShay: If the Lions felt good about Rousseau or Paye, either might help address a pass rush that has recorded just 18 sacks this season. Maybe wide receiver? Waddle is still available, and he’s the most elusive wideout in the class. Bateman is on the board, too. Remember, Kenny Golladay, Marvin Jones Jr. and Danny Amendola are all set to be free agents after the season.
Kiper: Yeah, I’m down to Lance, Wilson or Waddle with this pick. Lance is the upside quarterback pick — he’s going to be 20 years old when he’s drafted. But he’ll need time to adjust. Wilson is the hot name right now. Since we’re not making hypothetical trades in this exercise, this is the most logical spot for the third quarterback to land. Do you want to go with Wilson?
McShay: Yeah, let’s get the Lions their quarterback of the future to build around under a new coach and GM. Wilson is special.
10. Denver Broncos (4-8)
The consensus pick: Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah, ILB, Notre Dame
McShay: This is another spot to watch for a quarterback, right, Mel? I like Drew Lock, but have we seen enough?
Kiper: The Broncos need to seriously consider moving on from Lock — if they’re in position to get a quarterback they like. Is it fair to say that the Broncos have the fourth-best quarterback in the AFC West? That’s not good enough.
McShay: Yeah, I wish Denver had protected Lock a little better over the past two years because I don’t know that he’s been put in the best spot to succeed to this point. But I agree with you. If Wilson is available, I think he’s the pick. If he’s gone, like he is in this scenario, the Broncos need to think about whether they want to gamble on Lance with a top-10 pick. Cornerback is also a weakness, and if Surtain were to fall, he’d be a great get for Denver to close the top 10.
Kiper: If they don’t go quarterback, I’d lean secondary or linebacker. With Surtain gone at No. 6, that leaves Farley and Wade as my top-ranked corners. This is probably a little too high for both. What about Owusu-Koramoah? He’s perfect for today’s NFL as a rangy, sideline-to-sideline inside linebacker, and Denver could upgrade for its 3-4 defense.
McShay: I like it. He’d be a playmaker in the middle of that defense, impacting multiple facets of the game. Let’s go with him.
Kiper: That was fun, Todd. Let’s do it again soon. Looking forward to full first-round mock drafts in January.
|